Loading…
Just in:
Loading latest syndicated reports…

Top stories

Updated continuously

Akhilesh sets victory criterion for Congress seat allocations

Samajwadi Party president Akhilesh Yadav has insisted that prospects of victory, rather than numerical demands, will determine how his party divides constituencies with the Congress for the 2027 Uttar Pradesh Assembly elections.

Speaking at the party headquarters in Lucknow on Saturday, Yadav confirmed that the two parties would remain allies within the INDIA opposition bloc. He said the Congress would receive constituencies where its candidates had a credible chance of defeating the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP).

“When we examine the details minutely, there are still a lot of seats which the Congress can win; we will give them those seats,” Yadav said. He added: “Winnability is the only formula which can defeat the BJP in 2027.”

His remarks came ahead of negotiations scheduled to begin in New Delhi on Monday, November 23, over the division of Uttar Pradesh's 403 Assembly constituencies. Samajwadi Party MP Rajeev Rai had indicated the starting date, while Congress state working president Imran Masood confirmed plans for preliminary discussions.

The discussions are expected to run for two days, with further meetings possible if differences persist. Congress leaders want the arrangement settled by December 20. Rajendra Pal Gautam, the party's Uttar Pradesh in-charge, said an agreement by mid-December would leave the allies more time to prepare for the election. No agreed allocation has been announced, and neither party has formally disclosed a final demand.

Gautam also argued that electoral prospects could not be assessed independently of the issues facing voters. He said connecting people with those issues and selecting strong candidates would be important to securing support for whichever alliance partner contested a constituency.

The Congress has sought a substantial share of seats, while the Samajwadi Party has resisted treating the negotiations as a contest over fixed quotas. Yadav had earlier referred to a Congress request for 181 constituencies, although the party rejected a purported list of that number circulating on social media as its official proposal.

The differences reflect each party's assessment of its organisational strength and performance in earlier elections. The Samajwadi Party is the principal opposition force in Uttar Pradesh, while the Congress hopes to convert its parliamentary gains into a stronger presence in the state legislature.

The allies contested the 2024 Lok Sabha election together, winning 43 of Uttar Pradesh's 80 parliamentary constituencies. The Samajwadi Party secured 37 and the Congress six, while the BJP won 33, down from 62 in 2019. Their performance has become an important reference point in the negotiations.

The picture was different in the 2022 Assembly election, which the two parties fought separately. The Samajwadi Party won 111 constituencies and the Congress two. Those results underline the challenge of translating parliamentary cooperation into a workable division of Assembly seats.

Congress leaders have indicated that party general secretary Priyanka Gandhi Vadra could lead their delegation. The possible participants include Gautam, Masood, KC Venugopal and Uttar Pradesh Congress president Aradhana Misra Mona. The Samajwadi Party has identified senior leader Ram Gopal Yadav among those handling the discussions.

Both parties are seeking to challenge Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath's BJP government, which is pursuing a third consecutive Assembly term. Their immediate task is to reconcile competing constituency claims without undermining the alliance that delivered parliamentary gains in 2024.

Yadav used Saturday's briefing to address wider election preparations. He announced a website intended to gather suggestions, complaints and feedback, particularly from younger voters. The information would be compiled every two days and submitted to the party leadership, he said.

He also announced plans for a manifesto presented at three levels and urged party workers to strengthen booth-level organisation. He stressed the importance of ensuring that eligible voters were included on electoral rolls, an issue that has become another point of dispute between the opposition and the state government.

Yadav challenged claims by Adityanath concerning deleted Hindu voters and alleged that communities represented by the Samajwadi Party's PDA grouping, encompassing backward classes, Dalits and minorities, were being targeted. These assertions remain political allegations rather than independently established findings.

He said the party would send the Election Commission a memorandum signed by its legislators and parliamentarians alleging that some officials had operated in the BJP's interests and remained in their posts despite complaints. He also repeated his pledge to abolish the Agniveer military recruitment scheme if his party formed the government.

Hyderabad police tighten security after emailed bomb threats

Hyderabad police intensified security across the city on Sunday after receiving an email threatening bomb attacks at a railway station and nearby hotel, although an official said the message appeared to be a hoax.

The email, received at a city police address on Saturday, claimed links to the Pakistan-based militant organisation Lashkar-e-Taiba and threatened attacks modelled on the November 2008 Mumbai killings. Investigators are examining its authenticity and attempting to identify the sender.

The message named Kachiguda Railway Station and Hotel Tourist Plaza as potential targets and threatened to kill at least 300 people. Police have not established that the sender represents Lashkar-e-Taiba or that an attack is being prepared.

A police official described the email as a hoax but said an investigation remained under way. Authorities nevertheless initiated precautionary measures, conducted anti-sabotage inspections at locations identified in the warning and increased the deployment of uniformed personnel. The response was ordered despite an initial assessment that the warning might not represent a genuine terror threat.

Hyderabad City Police said in a statement that security arrangements had been strengthened immediately after the threatening communication was received. Cyber Crime Police officers have been assigned to trace the sender and determine the origins of the message.

The Special Branch circulated an alert to police units directing heightened vigilance at the named locations and elsewhere in Hyderabad. Officers were instructed to increase patrols, monitor movements around sensitive premises and maintain close coordination with other security agencies.

Security attention has extended beyond the two sites mentioned in the email. Railway and bus stations, hotels, places of worship, crowded public spaces and important installations have been identified for additional surveillance and checks.

Police personnel were instructed to watch for suspicious behaviour, unattended luggage, parked vehicles and unusual activity. The measures include bomb detection and anti-sabotage checks, particularly in areas attracting large numbers of passengers and visitors.

The sender allegedly used the subject line “Lashkar-E-Taiba” and invoked the attacks carried out in Mumbai on 26 November 2008. The email claimed that violence in Hyderabad would be retaliation for the killing of militant Lateef Bhat and associates by security forces in Jammu and Kashmir.

That assertion remains a claim made by the unidentified sender, rather than evidence of any operational connection with Lashkar-e-Taiba. Investigators are assessing whether the message was sent by someone impersonating the organisation, and police have not announced any finding establishing its provenance.

The wording circulated in a purported Special Branch communication suggested that attacks resembling those in Mumbai could take place on the anniversary, 26 November. Other accounts of the email did not establish a definite time for any proposed explosions. Authorities have not publicly confirmed a specific attack schedule.

The warning brought immediate attention to Kachiguda, an important transport area where the railway station and the hotel are situated close to each other. The reference to two identifiable public locations prompted security checks even as investigators questioned the credibility of the threat.

Hyderabad Police Commissioner Mahesh Muralidhar Bhagwat appealed to residents not to believe rumours and said preventive action had been taken. Police emphasised that vigilance should not be confused with confirmation of an imminent attack.

The city police also cautioned against circulating unverified messages, which could cause unnecessary alarm while officers investigate. Residents were asked to remain calm and report anything suspicious rather than draw conclusions from claims shared online.

The police statement said officers were working to maintain public safety and would continue to respond to information about possible dangers. It did not disclose any arrests, recovery of explosive material or evidence linking the threat to an organised plot.

The investigation involves tracing the threatening communication through cybercrime channels while local police carry out physical security checks. The two lines of inquiry address separate questions: who sent the message and whether any credible danger exists at the places identified.

Officials have not released the sender's identity or technical details about the email. The absence of a verified link to the organisation named in its subject line remains central to the assessment, despite the explicit references to mass casualties and the Mumbai attacks.

Police asked anyone noticing an unattended object or suspicious person to contact the emergency response number 112 immediately. They said personnel were available around the clock to receive alerts and act on information from the public.

MMRDA renews mosque removal order to Mumbai airport operator

Mumbai's metropolitan planning authority has instructed the city's airport operator to remove a mosque near Terminal 2 immediately, warning that failure to act could expose the company to formal legal proceedings.

The Mumbai Metropolitan Region Development Authority (MMRDA) reiterated that the structure was unauthorised and directed Mumbai International Airport Limited (MIAL) to take action. A notice has also been displayed at the mosque's entrance, making the authority's demand public. The warning specifically addresses the company managing the airport rather than treating the trust as the sole party responsible for compliance.

The fresh directive follows an earlier instruction issued in September. No demolition had been confirmed by Sunday, November 22, and the disputed structure remained near the arrival and taxi parking area of Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj International Airport.

The authority said documents presented by the Ashabul Janna Airport Charitable Trust, associated with the mosque, were insufficient, in its assessment, to establish that the structure could be treated as authorised under the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966. It consequently asked MIAL to arrange its removal without delay.

The order concerns land identified as City Survey number 1405 in Marol, adjoining the airport's international terminal. MMRDA has asked the operator to report the action taken to the deputy collector and the government department responsible for controlling unauthorised construction.

The authority referred to state Revenue and Forest Department circulars dated September 7, 2010, and October 10, 2013, in setting out the obligations relevant to the site. Its warning of possible proceedings against MIAL puts responsibility for implementing the directive squarely on the airport operator.

The mosque's representatives reject the allegation that the construction lacked permission. They maintain that approvals were obtained and that airport officials, including those associated with former operator GVK, knew of the prayer facility. They have cited a letter dating from 2015 in support of their position.

The competing claims have become the subject of legal and political disagreement, with the status of the trust's documents central to the dispute. All India Majlis-e-Ittehadul Muslimeen leader Waris Pathan has questioned the action, saying the dispute is before the Bombay High Court and should be resolved through legal proceedings rather than demolition carried out under political pressure.

Pathan also drew attention to a separate dispute over a mosque at Musafirkhana, where he said the court had stayed further action. That proceeding is distinct from the airport case, and his reference to it does not establish that an equivalent stay applies to the Marol structure.

Bharatiya Janata Party leader and former parliamentarian Kirit Somaiya, who has campaigned for the structure's removal, welcomed the renewed instructions. He alleged that the mosque occupied approximately 5,000 square feet of government land without approval and claimed it stood barely 50 metres from an airport gate.

Somaiya said he expected demolition within a week and sought criminal action against those he considers responsible for the construction. His proposed timetable is a political assertion, not confirmation that the operator has scheduled demolition or that police have registered a case.

MMRDA first formally challenged the mosque's status in a letter dated September 8, saying it had not granted planning permission for construction at the location. The authority also stated that the interim development plan governing the notified airport area did not allocate a plot for a public place of worship.

That communication referred to MIAL's obligations under the airport's operation, management and development agreement, which assigns responsibilities for planning, developing and maintaining facilities within the notified area. It called for action through the applicable legal procedures rather than removal outside the statutory process.

The controversy has also involved the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation. In September, the civic body asked airport management to produce evidence of an authorised water connection to the mosque or disconnect the supply within seven days. It said it had no valid record of permission for the connection.

The municipality's water-supply notice concerned a separate regulatory question from the land-use and planning issues raised by MMRDA. Neither the water notice nor the latest removal order, on its own, establishes that demolition has been carried out.

Somaiya visited the disputed site in September and subsequently organised a protest against the alleged encroachment in October. Police detained him and several supporters ahead of the proposed demonstration, amid concerns over public order near the airport premises.

Iran displays underground launcher for simultaneous missile strikes

Iran has unveiled an underground launcher designed to fire two liquid-fuelled missiles simultaneously, displaying its military capabilities as US President Donald Trump weighs further strikes against the country.

State television broadcast footage on Saturday showing senior commanders of the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps inspecting the system inside an extensive network of tunnels. The launcher's advertised capability has not been independently demonstrated, and Tehran has disclosed neither its precise specifications nor the location of the installation.

The display comes amid renewed uncertainty over whether Washington and Israel will expand their military campaign against Iran. Trump has considered additional joint strikes, although no decision to launch another offensive has been publicly announced. The White House has also examined potential Iranian retaliation, particularly against energy infrastructure in Gulf countries.

Major General Ahmad Vahidi, commander of the Revolutionary Guards, visited the underground complex alongside Brigadier General Seyyed Majid Mousavi, who leads the Guards' Aerospace Force. Footage showed the commanders travelling through passages lined with missiles, launching equipment and other military hardware.

Vahidi warned Iran's adversaries that the damage they had sustained was only the beginning. Mousavi said the force's capabilities had expanded substantially during the conflict and maintained that its newer weapons could deter further attacks. Their statements were assertions by Iranian commanders rather than independently established assessments of the country's arsenal.

The new equipment differs from an earlier Iranian twin-launcher design associated with solid-fuel missiles. Tehran says the latest arrangement accommodates two liquid-propellant weapons and allows them to be launched together. That could increase the number of missiles fired within a short period, although operational performance would depend on preparation, targeting and the availability of functioning missiles.

The choice of liquid fuel matters because it requires different handling and launch preparations from solid propellant. The advantages claimed by Tehran do not establish whether the system could survive an attack or launch repeatedly under combat conditions. No footage of a simultaneous firing accompanied the announcement.

Iranian state television also claimed improvements in missile accuracy, range and guidance, including navigation systems that do not depend on the American-operated Global Positioning System. The broadcaster offered no independently verifiable technical data establishing those improvements. It was also unclear when all the footage inside the installation had been recorded.

The demonstration appeared intended to challenge Washington's assessment of damage inflicted on Iran's missile infrastructure. American and Israeli forces have repeatedly targeted missile facilities and other military installations during the conflict, but the full extent of Iran's remaining production and launch capacity has not been publicly established.

The war began on 28 February with American and Israeli strikes on Iran that killed Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei. Tehran subsequently launched missiles and drones against targets across the region. The continuing hostilities have also disrupted shipping and energy markets, making the risk of a broader confrontation a significant concern for neighbouring governments.

Gulf governments have urged Washington to avoid another large military escalation, concerned that Iranian retaliation could threaten oil and gas facilities. Israel, meanwhile, has expressed alarm about Tehran's efforts to restore its missile production and protect strategic installations underground. These competing pressures have complicated deliberations over the next phase of American policy.

Iran's underground network forms part of its effort to shield military assets from aerial attacks. The Guards announced another underground missile installation earlier this month, describing facilities intended to store weapons and sustain production despite bombardment. Claims about the scale and survivability of those sites remain difficult to assess without outside access.

Alongside the military display, Iranian Deputy Foreign Minister Kazem Gharibabadi said Tehran remained in contact with Qatari mediators who visited the country on Friday to examine whether diplomacy could be revived. His remarks indicated that channels for discussions had not entirely closed despite the exchanges of military warnings.

Tensions around the Strait of Hormuz have added urgency to those contacts. Britain's maritime security authorities said two tankers were struck by projectiles while leaving the Gulf on Saturday, with no casualties immediately reported. Iran's navy separately said a tanker had hit a mine east of the strait and caught fire.

The Revolutionary Guards' footage showed missiles and launchers stored inside long underground corridors, but did not establish how many of the weapons were ready for immediate deployment. Iranian authorities have not published the new launcher's firing rate, missile types or deployment timetable.

US rejects Iranian missile claim amid F-16 flight questions

US Central Command has rejected Iran’s claim that its air defences damaged an American F-16 fighter jet over the Gulf, as disputed flight-tracking accounts circulate about an emergency signal and a sharp descent near the United Arab Emirates.

The command said on Saturday that Iranian forces had not attacked an American F-16 on Friday, November 20. “Iran did not attack a US F-16 fighter aircraft yesterday — at all,” it said, adding that every US military fighter jet operating in the Middle East was safe and accounted for.

Iran’s army had asserted that an air defence missile detonated near the aircraft on Friday evening, damaging it and forcing its pilot to abandon the mission before making an emergency landing. The competing statements have left the alleged engagement unsubstantiated, with no independently verified evidence establishing that an American fighter sustained missile damage.

Accounts circulating alongside the Iranian announcement described an F-16 transmitting the aviation emergency transponder code 7700 near the UAE at approximately 32,200 feet. They claimed flight-tracking information recorded the aircraft descending to about 4,500 feet, a change of roughly 27,700 feet, before diverting towards Al Dhafra Air Base outside Abu Dhabi.

Those figures have not been independently established as a complete, authenticated flight record linked to the aircraft identified in Iran’s statement. Nor has the US military publicly confirmed that the reported emergency transmission, descent and diversion formed part of a missile encounter. A transponder alert alone cannot determine whether an aircraft has been attacked.

Code 7700 is the internationally recognised signal for a general aircraft emergency. It can be used for various technical, operational or medical circumstances and does not specify their cause. Likewise, a descent shown on a tracking service, even if accurately attributed, would not establish combat damage without corroborating information about the aircraft and its subsequent inspection.

Iranian authorities presented the purported incident as evidence that their air defence network had engaged an American combat aircraft over the Gulf. The army said its systems tracked the jet and launched a missile, with an explosion near the target allegedly compelling an emergency landing. Tehran did not provide independently verifiable documentation of the damage claimed.

The episode was associated in some accounts with Qeshm Island, an Iranian territory in the Strait of Hormuz, where military activity has intensified. Claims that an Iranian anti-ship missile launch against vessels under US naval escort preceded the alleged fighter encounter have also circulated, but the precise sequence and any direct operational connection remain unconfirmed.

The distinction matters because the location is close to one of the world’s most heavily scrutinised maritime passages. Aircraft movements, naval operations and missile launches around the strait can quickly attract attention, while incomplete public tracking information can leave considerable uncertainty about exactly what occurred.

Iran also claimed on Saturday to have brought down a US drone over Qeshm Island. That assertion was separate from the F-16 allegation and should not be taken as supporting evidence for it. An American military official had confirmed that US aircraft struck an Iranian missile site on the island earlier in the week.

The latest exchange unfolded amid renewed threats to commercial shipping. Britain’s maritime security authorities recorded separate projectile strikes against two tankers departing the Gulf through the Strait of Hormuz on Saturday. Iran’s navy separately said a tanker had struck a naval mine east of the strait and caught fire, an account that was not independently reconciled with the other incidents.

The contrasting accounts underscore the difficulty of establishing what happens during fast-moving military incidents involving aircraft and missiles. The Iranian description specifies an engagement and damage, while the American response disputes that an attack took place at all. Neither the alleged altitude change nor the emergency code, on its own, resolves that central disagreement.

The reported altitude figures have nevertheless prompted questions about the jet’s condition and the circumstances of its descent. No aircraft serial number, inspection finding or pilot account has been made public to substantiate the suggested connection with Iranian fire.

Al Dhafra, the air base named in the circulated diversion accounts, hosts US military aircraft alongside UAE forces. Publicly accessible flight tracking can provide useful indications of aircraft movements, but military flights may appear only partially, and the data visible to users need not establish an aircraft’s identity, mission or condition.

Supreme Court denies priority listing for election plea

The Supreme Court on Friday declined an urgent hearing sought by advocate Prashant Bhushan to recall a September 23 split verdict concerning challenges to the law governing appointments to the Election Commission.

A three-judge bench headed by Chief Justice of India Surya Kant said the objections could be raised before the five-judge Constitution Bench constituted to examine the validity of the Chief Election Commissioner and Other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023.

Bhushan had requested that the recall application be placed before Justices Dipankar Datta and Satish Chandra Sharma, who delivered the divided ruling. He argued that an alleged conflict of interest involving Justice Sharma required the original bench to reconsider its order referring the dispute to a larger bench.

The allegation concerns Justice Sharma's son, who serves as standing counsel for the Election Commission of India before the Madhya Pradesh High Court. The application questions whether that professional connection created a conflict of interest. The allegation has not been judicially established.

Bhushan emphasised that Justice Sharma was due to retire at the end of the following week and pressed for the application to be heard before his retirement. He maintained that the request challenged the reference order itself, rather than merely raising an issue to be examined during arguments on the legislation.

Justice Joymalya Bagchi, who sat with the Chief Justice and Justice V Mohana, indicated that the Constitution Bench could consider the validity of the reference. The larger bench was not prevented from framing a question about whether the matter had properly been referred, he observed.

The Chief Justice also indicated that a recall application could be considered after a member of the original bench had retired. The court therefore did not accept the approaching retirement as grounds for an immediate, separate listing.

The exchanges did not settle the allegation of conflict of interest or determine the constitutional validity of the appointments law. They concerned the forum and timing for considering the procedural challenge. The petitioners retain the opportunity to advance their objection when the Constitution Bench hears the matter.

During the hearing, Bhushan argued that Justice Sharma's opinion had been decisive in bringing about the reference. He suggested that without the disagreement between the two judges, there would have been no occasion to send the dispute to a larger bench.

The Chief Justice distinguished his administrative role in constituting the larger bench from the judicial opinions delivered in September. Bhushan clarified that he was not challenging the Chief Justice's administrative action but seeking reconsideration of the order made by the original bench.

The September 23 ruling followed disagreement over whether the constitutional questions presented by the petitions required adjudication by five judges. Justice Datta considered a larger reference unnecessary, while Justice Sharma held that the issues merited consideration by a Constitution Bench.

The two judges nevertheless agreed that the matter should be placed before the Chief Justice for appropriate action. The dispute over the reference has now become an additional procedural question alongside the original challenge to the 2023 statute.

The legislation provides for appointments to the posts of Chief Election Commissioner and Election Commissioners through a selection committee comprising the Prime Minister, the Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha and a Union Cabinet Minister nominated by the Prime Minister.

It replaced the Chief Justice of India on the selection committee with a Cabinet Minister. The preceding arrangement had been prescribed by the Supreme Court in March 2023, pending legislation by Parliament.

Petitioners, including the Association for Democratic Reforms, contend that the new arrangement gives the executive an overriding influence in choosing members of the Election Commission. They argue that this raises constitutional concerns about the independence of the body responsible for administering elections.

The Union government has defended the statutory framework against the constitutional challenge. The merits of those competing positions remain for judicial determination and were not decided during Friday's brief hearing on the recall application.

The September proceedings also involved petitions brought by Jaya Thakur and other applicants challenging specific provisions of the Act. The contested provisions deal with the composition of the selection committee and the process governing appointments to the Election Commission. Their petitions also contest the exclusion of the Chief Justice from the selection process established under the contested legislation.

NIA chief disputes VanDyke torture allegations in Tihar

National Investigation Agency director general Rakesh Aggarwal has rejected allegations of custodial torture made by US national Matthew VanDyke, saying he did not complain to a Delhi court during repeated appearances while imprisoned in Tihar Jail.

Aggarwal said on Friday that VanDyke had been produced before a judge about six or seven times during his custody but had not alleged mistreatment. The comments followed VanDyke's publication of allegations that he was assaulted and denied medical attention while detained for nearly six months.

The NIA chief distinguished the allegations against prison personnel from the conduct of the investigating agency. He said VanDyke had not accused NIA officers of assault and indicated that complaints made during court proceedings would have been examined. His remarks do not independently establish whether the alleged attacks occurred. Nor does the absence of a complaint during the cited hearings, by itself, resolve the dispute over conditions in the prison.

VanDyke, who was arrested with six Ukrainian nationals in March over alleged unauthorised travel through India into Myanmar, has accused prison staff of repeatedly attacking him. A handwritten affidavit prepared in August describes being punched in the chest, struck with a baton and deprived of urgently needed medical assistance for almost 24 hours.

The American posted the allegations publicly this month. He also claimed that his imprisonment and that of the Ukrainian defendants was connected to Russia's war against Ukraine. No evidence establishing that alleged connection has emerged from the proceedings described by investigators, and the NIA has not accepted his account.

The affidavit, which VanDyke said he sent to the US embassy, was prepared before the agency submitted its chargesheet. He asked embassy officials to convey his concerns to authorities and indicated he might pursue legal and public disclosure of the alleged assaults. The allegations have not been adjudicated by a court. There has been no independently verified medical assessment or prison inquiry placed in the public domain that conclusively supports or refutes the account.

Aggarwal also addressed a separate question concerning the criminal investigation: why the NIA had not included terrorism offences in the chargesheet despite initially investigating the case under the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, or UAPA.

He said investigators were examining data to establish whether any insurgent organisation from India had benefited from training allegedly provided by VanDyke and the six Ukrainians in Myanmar. The agency had not yet established the identities of alleged beneficiaries sufficiently to support additional charges, he said.

“We are sifting through it (data) to establish whether any Indian insurgent group benefited from their training. If we are able to establish that, we will chargesheet them,” Aggarwal said. His statement made clear that further prosecution under the UAPA remains conditional on evidence identifying the people allegedly trained.

The NIA maintains that the seven foreigners entered India on valid visas, travelled to Mizoram without the necessary permits, crossed into Myanmar by unauthorised routes and later returned through similar routes. Aggarwal said the investigation into their movements had been completed and charges filed on that aspect.

The chargesheet invokes Sections 21 and 23 of the Immigration and Foreigners Act, 2025, rather than provisions of the anti-terrorism law. Investigators have kept the broader inquiry open and could file a supplementary chargesheet if they establish further offences. The allegations of militant training remain contested, and the defendants have not been convicted of those offences. The distinction between immigration violations and alleged terrorist activity is significant because the latter would require evidence supporting the statutory elements of a separate offence.

VanDyke was granted default bail after a court found the chargesheet insufficient to prevent his statutory release while the UAPA investigation remained unfinished. His release did not amount to a judicial finding that the entire prosecution case was unfounded.

The Delhi court subsequently allowed VanDyke and the Ukrainian defendants to remain abroad until 24 February 2027, when the matter is scheduled for further hearing. VanDyke returned to India once after securing bail to attend court proceedings, Aggarwal said.

The NIA arrested the seven at different airports after investigating their alleged movements across the Myanmar border. The agency has also examined whether the armed groups involved had connections with insurgent networks operating in India's northeastern region. The precise identities of those allegedly trained remain a central unresolved issue in the still continuing investigation.

Former air force vice-chief disputes Rafale inventory count

Former Air Force vice-chief Air Marshal Narmdeshwar Tiwari has rejected a British aviation directory's assessment that India operates only 32 Rafale fighters, disputing figures that have renewed arguments over aircraft losses during last year's conflict with Pakistan.

Tiwari, who was vice-chief during Operation Sindoor in May 2025, described the assessment as “patently false” and urged FlightGlobal to reconsider the information used to compile its annual World Air Forces directory. India purchased 36 Rafales from France, while the publication's 2027 edition lists 32 as active.

The discrepancy has prompted objections from serving Air Force sources, who maintain that the published figure is wrong and that the service did not supply its fleet data to the publication. Neither FlightGlobal's figures nor the objections provide a publicly verified, aircraft-by-aircraft accounting of the fleet's present operational status. The competing assessments leave unresolved whether the difference concerns aircraft availability, permanent losses or the methodology used to categorise individual jets.

“FlightGlobal should re-evaluate their sources,” Tiwari wrote on X on Thursday. He said sources associated with earlier claims had identified individual Rafales as destroyed, although aircraft bearing those identifiers subsequently participated in flying exercises, including international engagements.

Tiwari also questioned previous assertions that Squadron Leader Shivangi Singh had been captured by Pakistan during the hostilities. Singh subsequently appeared publicly alongside President Droupadi Murmu at Ambala airbase, contradicting the prisoner-of-war allegation.

The annual directory, prepared using aviation data provider Cirium's military fleet information, gives no explanation for the latest reduction. It does not identify the four aircraft missing from the total acquired or establish whether any discrepancy arises from combat losses, maintenance, classification differences or incomplete records.

The previous edition, issued in November 2025, listed 35 Rafales as active. Its latest count therefore represents a reduction of three against that estimate, although the published total is four below the 36 aircraft delivered under India's original procurement agreement.

Defence officials have challenged the provenance of the data, stressing that it was not provided by the Ministry of Defence. Their objections underline the distinction between externally compiled fleet estimates and information confirmed by the military operator, which has not published a detailed inventory resolving the discrepancy.

Officials have also cited an Air Force tender issued in June 2026 seeking a temporary maintenance and technical support arrangement covering all 36 Rafale aircraft. The procurement document provides evidence that support planning continued on the basis of the full original fleet, although a maintenance tender does not independently establish that every aircraft was combat-ready at a particular time.

The dispute has revived competing accounts of the aerial fighting during Operation Sindoor, launched on 7 May 2025 following the killing of 26 people in an attack at Pahalgam. Pakistan claimed to have shot down several aircraft, including Rafales, during the subsequent clashes.

India's military acknowledged aircraft losses during the fighting but did not publicly specify their number and types. It disputed Pakistan's higher claims about the scale of the losses. Consequently, assertions that the directory verifies four Rafales were destroyed go beyond what its published figures establish.

The Rafale's manufacturer, Dassault Aviation, has also challenged Pakistani assertions. Chief executive Éric Trappier described claims about Rafale shootdowns as inaccurate in June 2025 while indicating that authorities in India had not provided the company with details of any such losses.

FlightGlobal's inventory is designed to provide a comparative account of military aviation holdings worldwide. Its use of third-party information means the published category of active aircraft should not automatically be equated with a government-certified count of aircraft available for immediate operations.

Cirium draws on aircraft identification information, public sightings, flight records and aviation-related reporting to maintain fleet datasets. Such methods can help track individual airframes but may not fully capture the status of military aircraft whose movements and maintenance information are not routinely disclosed.

The controversy comes as India pursues plans to acquire additional Rafale fighters, separate from the 36 aircraft already delivered to the Air Force. The service's original fleet comprises single-seat and twin-seat variants produced by Dassault Aviation under the agreement signed with France in 2016.

The latest directory places the Rafale DH/EH model under the Air Force entry for India, using its active-aircraft column to show 32. The directory's published table does not accompany that figure with individual aircraft serial numbers or explanations for changes from the preceding edition.

US court hands Nikhil Gupta 235-month prison term

A US federal court sentenced Nikhil Gupta to 19 years and seven months in prison on Friday for his role in a failed plot to assassinate Sikh separatist Gurpatwant Singh Pannun in New York.

US District Judge Victor Marrero imposed the 235-month sentence in Manhattan after Gupta, 55, pleaded guilty in February to murder-for-hire, conspiracy to commit murder-for-hire and conspiracy to commit money laundering. The prosecution said the operation was directed by a government employee from India.

The sentence followed competing requests from prosecutors, who sought more than 24 years, and defence lawyers, who asked for 12 years. Gupta apologised to Pannun and others affected by the conspiracy during the hearing. His lawyers pointed to his lack of previous criminal convictions and personal circumstances in seeking leniency.

Pannun, a US citizen and lawyer who advocates an independent Sikh homeland called Khalistan, addressed the court. He described the threat to his life and accused the government of Prime Minister Narendra Modi of attempting to intimidate separatist campaigners. That accusation was made by Pannun and was not itself the subject of a conviction against any government official.

Gupta faces removal to India after serving his prison term, Judge Marrero indicated at the hearing. The sentence was shorter than the term sought by prosecutors but substantially longer than the punishment requested by his defence. In court, Gupta expressed regret for the consequences of his actions for his family as well as for Pannun. Pannun, meanwhile, said he intended to continue campaigning for Sikh self-determination despite the threat.

The US Attorney for the Southern District of New York, Jamie McDonald, said the punishment demonstrated that attempts to organise violence against people in the United States would be prosecuted regardless of where the planning occurred.

Gupta's guilty plea established his responsibility for arranging an assassination attempt, although the intended killing never took place. Federal investigators had infiltrated the operation before the conspirators could carry it out.

Prosecutors identified Vikash Yadav, who worked in India's Cabinet Secretariat, as the official who recruited Gupta in May 2023 and directed the scheme. Yadav faces charges in the United States but has not been arrested in connection with the case. The allegations against him remain unproven in court.

The Justice Department said Gupta contacted a person he believed could arrange a contract killing. The intermediary was a confidential source working with the Drug Enforcement Administration, who introduced Gupta to an undercover officer posing as a hired assassin.

Federal authorities said the agreed price for Pannun's murder was $100,000. An associate delivered $15,000 as an advance in June 2023. Prosecutors said Gupta subsequently passed the supposed assassin Pannun's home address, telephone details and information about his movements, and relayed surveillance photographs and updates to Yadav.

Investigators also documented communications about the timing of the proposed killing. Gupta instructed the undercover officer to avoid carrying it out during Modi's state visit to Washington in June 2023, according to the prosecution's account.

The case became a sensitive issue between Washington and New Delhi after federal prosecutors disclosed the alleged connection to a serving government employee. India's Ministry of External Affairs previously described the alleged involvement of an official as contrary to government policy and said the matter would be examined. The government subsequently acknowledged conducting an inquiry into the allegations.

Pannun is designated a terrorist under India's Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, while his organisation, Sikhs for Justice, is banned in India. Those designations do not apply under US law. In the United States, Pannun's political advocacy and his status as a citizen were central to concerns expressed about the alleged cross-border assassination operation.

Gupta was arrested in the Czech Republic on June 30, 2023, at the request of US authorities and extradited to America in June 2024. He initially contested the charges before entering his guilty plea this February.

The assassination allegations also surfaced amid scrutiny of the June 2023 killing of Sikh separatist Hardeep Singh Nijjar in Canada. American prosecutors said messages obtained during their investigation referred to Nijjar after his death. The proceedings against Gupta, however, concerned the separate plan targeting Pannun in New York.

Alongside the custodial sentence, the court imposed a $300 special assessment. Investigators from the Federal Bureau of Investigation and the Drug Enforcement Administration worked on the case, with assistance from Czech authorities.

Muslims projected to outnumber Christians worldwide by 2035

Muslims are projected to overtake Christians as the world's largest religious group by 2035, with sweeping population changes also expected across India, the United States and Africa, according to new Pew Research Center forecasts.

The study, released on 18 November, projects that Muslims will account for 35.8% of the global population by 2070, compared with 29.1% for Christians. Both communities are expected to increase in absolute numbers, but the Muslim population is forecast to expand much faster over the next five decades.

Pew estimates that the number of Muslims will rise from 2.02 billion in 2020 to 3.64 billion in 2070, an increase of 80%. The Christian population is projected to grow by about 30%, reaching just under three billion, against an estimated 29% increase in the world's overall population.

India is expected to have the world's second-largest Muslim population by 2070, with approximately 334 million followers of Islam, behind Pakistan's projected 461 million. Nigeria would rank third, while Indonesia, which had the largest Muslim population in 2020, would move to fourth place.

Despite the increase, Hindus are projected to remain a substantial majority in India, accounting for approximately 76% of its population in 2070, compared with 79% in 2020. The Muslim share is forecast to rise from about 15% to 20%, reflecting differences in age profiles and fertility rates rather than an anticipated reversal of the country's religious majority.

The United States is meanwhile projected to lose its Christian majority by 2065. Christians would represent about 48% of Americans in 2070, down from approximately 64% in 2020, although Christianity would remain the country's largest religious affiliation.

Americans identifying with no religion, including atheists, agnostics and people who describe themselves as having no particular faith, are forecast to increase from 30% to 41% of the population. Pew attributes much of the change to people raised Christian leaving religious affiliation, alongside differences in the age structure of religious communities.

The number of Christians in the United States is projected to decline from 217 million to 174 million by 2070. The Democratic Republic of the Congo is expected to replace it as the country with the largest Christian population, with its Christian population forecast to triple to roughly 299 million.

Sub-Saharan Africa is central to the projected growth of both religions. More than half of the world's Christians are expected to live there by 2070, as expanding populations offset shrinking Christian communities in parts of Europe and North America. The region's Muslim population is forecast to climb from 369 million to 980 million.

The demographic differences are substantial. Pew estimated that Muslim women had an average of 3.1 children in the 2020–2025 period, compared with 2.5 for Christian women. Muslims also had a median age of 24 in 2020, against 33 among people outside Islam, giving the community a comparatively youthful population.

The projections account for births, deaths, migration and changes in religious identification. They describe what could happen if observed demographic patterns continue, rather than predicting future religious choices with certainty. Changes in fertility, migration policies or patterns of disaffiliation could alter the figures.

Although the share of Americans without a religious identity is forecast to rise, the proportion of unaffiliated people worldwide is expected to fall from approximately 24% in 2020 to 17% in 2070. Population decline in China, home to a large proportion of the world's unaffiliated people, is a major factor behind that global divergence.

Europe is expected to experience its own shift, with Muslims increasing from 6% to 13% of the population by 2070 and the religiously unaffiliated rising from approximately one-quarter to one-third. Christianity is nevertheless projected to remain the region's largest religious category. Pew also expects people without a religious affiliation to become majorities in France and the United Kingdom by the year 2070.

Across Asia and the Pacific, Muslims are projected to surpass the religiously unaffiliated as the largest group by 2040, with Hindus moving into second place. The Middle East and North Africa, by contrast, are expected to experience comparatively little change in their religious composition, with Muslims accounting for about 95% of residents by 2070.

Pew expects the number of Muslim-majority countries and territories to rise from 53 to 54, with Ivory Coast joining the group. The number of Christian-majority countries is projected to decline from 120 to 110.

Delhi murder suspect Naseem Durrani dies in police shootout

Gangster Naseem Durrani, wanted over the killing of a man near Delhi Law Minister Kapil Mishra’s office, was shot dead during a joint police operation in Uttar Pradesh’s Bulandshahr early on Friday.

The 37-year-old died after an exchange of gunfire involving Delhi Police and the Uttar Pradesh Special Task Force (STF), officials said. Investigators had been pursuing him in connection with the November 16 killing of Sameer, 26, in northeast Delhi.

Additional Director General of Police Amitabh Yash said officers received intelligence that Durrani was in Bulandshahr and attempting to escape. Police intercepted him in the Secunderabad police station area at approximately 1am, triggering the confrontation, according to Yash.

Police said Durrani opened fire when officers attempted to stop him. Investigators said officers first spotted him riding a scooter near the Sikandra bypass. As the team approached, he allegedly accelerated before the vehicle skidded and he fell. Police maintained that he then fired at the approaching personnel, prompting them to respond with gunfire. Officers returned fire, and he suffered gunshot injuries to his chest. He was taken to hospital, where he was declared dead. Authorities said two.32-bore pistols were recovered at the encounter scene.

Accounts of the number of shots fired varied. Yash put the exchange at approximately 15 to 20 rounds, while another police account indicated about 20 to 22 rounds. The sequence of events described by officers has not been independently established.

The operation involved personnel from Delhi Police and the STF’s Noida unit, following extensive efforts to track the suspect after Sameer’s death. Police said intelligence and CCTV footage helped locate Durrani and follow his movements in Bulandshahr.

Investigators alleged that Durrani was involved in the fatal shooting near Mishra’s camp office in the Sonia Vihar area on Monday. The victim, identified as Sameer, was attacked while travelling on a scooter near Zero Pusta, police said.

Two attackers riding a motorcycle approached from behind and opened fire, according to the police account. Sameer sustained multiple gunshot wounds and was taken to a trauma centre in Civil Lines, where doctors declared him dead.

Police said the shooting occurred at around 5.30pm and was brought to their attention later that evening. Investigators examined the scene, collected forensic evidence and reviewed surveillance footage to identify the assailants and reconstruct their route.

Some police accounts put the number of rounds fired during the attack at approximately 16, while others cited about 20. The precise number remains unclear. Durrani’s alleged involvement had not been determined by a court before his death.

A murder case was registered at Sonia Vihar police station, and multiple teams were assigned to identify and locate suspects. Officials said Durrani emerged as a person wanted in the investigation, leading to the operation across the state border.

Delhi Police had offered a reward of Rs 50,000 for information leading to his arrest. Yash said Durrani was named in more than 26 criminal cases registered in Delhi and Uttar Pradesh, including allegations of murder, attempted murder and extortion.

Police also alleged that Durrani had connections to D-Company, the organised crime network associated with fugitive gangster Dawood Ibrahim, and maintained links with underworld operative Chhota Shakeel. Those alleged associations form part of the police account of his activities.

Yash said Durrani had allegedly been recruited by Shakeel in 2017 for a plot to kill rival gangster Chhota Rajan while Rajan was held at Tihar Jail. Police said the alleged plan was thwarted before it could be carried out.

The officer also linked Durrani to an alleged conspiracy targeting Pakistani-born writer Tariq Fatah. These were allegations outlined by investigators, rather than findings reached in the proceedings arising from Friday’s encounter.

According to STF records, Durrani used the names Naseem and Rizwan. Police described him as operating with associates in northeast Delhi and cited earlier cases involving firearms and attacks on officers.

One case registered at Gokulpuri police station in 2014 concerned an alleged assault on police personnel during an attempt to help a suspect escape custody. Police records also listed a murder case registered there in 2010 and other cases at Khajuri Khas, Jafrabad and Dayalpur police stations.

Officials additionally suspected Durrani of involvement in another killing in the Khajuri Khas area during the preceding six months. They have not publicly established his responsibility for that death.

Padmaja Venugopal leaves BJP citing ideological differences

Padmaja Venugopal, daughter of former Kerala Chief Minister K Karunakaran, has resigned from the Bharatiya Janata Party, describing her decision to abandon the Congress in 2024 as a mistake made in haste.

Announcing her departure on Thursday, November 19, Venugopal said she had struggled to reconcile her beliefs with the BJP's ideology. She maintained that party leaders had treated her well and that her resignation should not be interpreted as a personal complaint against them.

The former BJP National Council member said she had submitted her resignation to Kerala BJP president Rajeev Chandrasekhar and forwarded a copy to the party's national leadership, citing personal reasons. She disclosed that the resignation had preceded her public announcement. She said she had delayed discussing her decision openly, although she had already communicated it to the party leadership.

Venugopal has not decided whether to rejoin the Congress, although her departure has prompted an open invitation from its Kerala leadership and opposition from some party functionaries. Kerala Pradesh Congress Committee president Sunny Joseph said he would welcome her return.

State Congress spokesperson Jinto John objected, arguing that leaders who left the organisation for the BJP should not be readmitted without consideration of their criticism of Congress workers and the party leadership. His intervention highlighted differences within the organisation over how to respond to her departure. John argued that the leadership should consider the feelings of ordinary party workers who had defended the Congress during Venugopal’s time in the BJP.

Venugopal said she had realised soon after joining the BJP that its political outlook differed from her own. She explained that she had remained with the party rather than leave immediately after discovering those differences.

"Their ideology and mine didn't quite align," she told reporters, adding that she had no grievance about the treatment she received. She said the original decision was hers alone and that she now wanted to correct it.

She joined the BJP on March 7, 2024, after leaving the Congress amid dissatisfaction with its Kerala organisation, particularly in Thrissur. At the time, she alleged that some Congress colleagues had undermined her political prospects and failed to address complaints she had raised.

On Thursday, she said the move had followed a period of distress and had been made without sufficient reflection or consultation. She maintained that she still disagreed with the conduct of certain Congress leaders in Thrissur but no longer felt angry towards them.

Venugopal also rejected suggestions that she was leaving because she had been denied an appointment within the BJP. She said she had neither sought nor received a promise of any position, and that her decision was not linked to expectations of a change in Kerala's government.

She dismissed the suggestion that her departure was calculated to benefit from the Congress-led United Democratic Front's electoral success, asking why she had not returned before the Assembly election if that had been her motivation.

The former Congress leader contested the 2026 Kerala Assembly election from Thrissur on a BJP ticket and finished third. She had previously contested the constituency for the Congress in 2016 and 2021, losing on both occasions.

Venugopal said her immediate priority was to participate in programmes preserving her father's political legacy, something she found difficult while belonging to the BJP. She said remaining outside a political party would allow her greater freedom to undertake those activities.

She acknowledged that her family background continued to connect her to the Congress, but stressed that no decision on membership had been reached. She also said she had not negotiated with Congress leaders about returning.

Her brother, senior Congress leader K Muraleedharan, was the only family political figure she said she had consulted over the decision. According to Venugopal, he advised her to do whatever would bring her happiness and peace of mind.

BJP MP from Thrissur and Union Minister Suresh Gopi said the resignation was a matter for the party's state leadership. He said he had not obstructed Venugopal's entry into the party and had no authority to oppose her exit.

Asked about Prime Minister Narendra Modi, Venugopal said she recognised achievements as well as mistakes in his administration, but declined to offer a detailed assessment. She also said she did not regard every BJP member as communal, distinguishing her ideological differences from her experience of individual party colleagues.

Supreme Court declines fresh hearing on Ujjain mosque demolition

The Supreme Court has dismissed a petition seeking reconsideration of its decision against intervening in the demolition of Takiya Masjid in Ujjain, Madhya Pradesh, rejecting a separate request for an open-court hearing.

Justices Vikram Nath and Sandeep Mehta, examining the papers in chambers, ruled on November 17 that their November 7, 2025 order contained no apparent error justifying a review. The judges did not grant permission for oral arguments, despite the petitioners asking to be heard in open court. The decision leaves undisturbed the earlier dismissal of a challenge brought by worshippers who opposed the removal of the mosque near the Mahakal Temple complex.

The order, issued in the case of Mohammed Taiyab versus the State of Madhya Pradesh and others, states that the judges had examined the review petition and the grounds advanced in support of it. They found no basis for reopening the previous decision. The application seeking an oral hearing was rejected, and pending applications were disposed of.

The proceedings were conducted by circulation, a procedure under which judges consider a review petition on the written record rather than automatically scheduling arguments in open court. The ruling does not contain a fresh, detailed examination of the competing claims about the acquisition or demolition. Its immediate effect is to maintain the Supreme Court's refusal to interfere with the earlier High Court judgment.

The original challenge came from 13 residents who said they had worshipped at Takiya Masjid. They contended that the mosque, which they described as approximately 200 years old, was demolished in January 2025 following the acquisition of land intended to enlarge parking facilities serving the adjoining Mahakal Temple and Mahakal Lok complex.

The petitioners maintained that the mosque had been notified as waqf property in 1985 and remained a functioning place of worship until its demolition. They argued that the authorities had acted unlawfully and sought reconstruction of the building, together with an inquiry into the conduct of officials involved in the exercise.

Their objections cited the Places of Worship (Special Provisions) Act, 1991, provisions governing waqf property and the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013. They also questioned the acquisition process, alleging that compensation had been directed to people who lacked lawful entitlement. Those assertions formed part of the petitioners' case and were not established by the Supreme Court's review order.

The Madhya Pradesh High Court had rejected the worshippers' application for reconstruction on September 4, 2025. Justice Pranay Verma held that proceedings concerning acquisition of the relevant land had already been adjudicated and that the mosque committee had withdrawn its own challenge to the acquisition in April that year.

The High Court concluded that the worshippers could not reopen the acquisition question through a separate petition after the mosque committee's withdrawal and earlier judicial decisions concerning the same land. It also noted that the Madhya Pradesh Waqf Board had instituted separate proceedings concerning title before the Waqf Tribunal in Bhopal, but found that the existence of that suit did not alter the outcome of the petition before it.

A subsequent appeal by the worshippers failed, leading to their approach to the Supreme Court. On November 7, 2025, the bench declined to overturn the High Court's ruling. The review application then sought to persuade the same court that the earlier refusal required reconsideration.

The acquisition itself arose from a proposal by the Shri Mahakaleshwar temple management committee for additional vehicle parking. An earlier High Court judgment recorded that the state authorities had issued an acquisition notification in November 2022 covering approximately 2.135 hectares, with compensation awards following in 2024.

That judgment, concerning challenges by affected residents, also addressed disputes over compensation and rehabilitation. The High Court pointed to a statutory route for contesting the amount or distribution of compensation and related resettlement entitlements, while declining to invalidate the acquisition. The court granted additional time for affected appellants to pursue those remedies.

The November 17 Supreme Court record identifies the review as arising from special leave petition number 31842 of 2025. Alongside the request for an open-court hearing, the record lists an application seeking a separate interim stay. Both were disposed of when the review petition was dismissed. The court’s signed order was issued in New Delhi and records the names of both judges.

Congress challenges Modi over jobs and investment criticism

The Congress accused Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Thursday of blaming businesses for weak hiring, stagnant wages and subdued investment while refusing to acknowledge the effects of his government's economic policies.

Congress general secretary Jairam Ramesh said Modi's questions to corporate leaders at the Federation of Indian Chambers of Commerce and Industry (FICCI) annual general meeting in New Delhi reflected problems the opposition had repeatedly highlighted. He argued that government decisions, rather than employers alone, were responsible for the conditions described by the Prime Minister.

Ramesh, writing on X after the address, said Modi had criticised industry leaders over their failure to expand employment and raise pay despite tax concessions. He accused the government of concentrating economic power, weakening competition and undermining confidence among potential investors.

"But the PM has been less than fair. His policies have led to this situation," Ramesh said, disputing the suggestion that corporate decisions could be considered separately from the government's economic record.

The dispute centred on whether tax relief alone could stimulate hiring and investment, or whether broader government policy was also shaping corporate decisions. The exchange followed Modi's challenge to businesses to explain why reductions in taxes had not produced corresponding improvements in employment and wages. Speaking at Bharat Mandapam during FICCI's centenary convention, he pointed to the reduction in the basic corporate tax rate from 30 per cent to 22 per cent and income tax relief for individuals earning up to Rs 12 lakh annually.

Modi asked whether employers had raised salaries or increased their workforce after benefiting from a more favourable tax environment. His remarks placed greater responsibility on companies to translate fiscal incentives and stronger purchasing power into jobs, employee earnings and investment.

The Prime Minister also defended the government's economic programme, citing measures to simplify tax returns and refunds, reduce goods and services tax rates on numerous products and support domestic demand. He described India as the fastest-growing major economy and referred to growth projections of around seven per cent.

Ramesh countered that lower corporate taxes had not generated the investment expansion anticipated by the government. He said employment had failed to grow sufficiently and wages had not increased as expected, maintaining that the Prime Minister was effectively acknowledging criticisms raised by Congress.

"For the first time in 12 years, a nervous and rattled PM has pulled up the captains of industry," Ramesh wrote. His description of Modi's state of mind was a political characterisation rather than an independently established assessment.

The Congress leader further alleged that excessive concentration of market power had produced oligopolistic structures across industries. He claimed that this had restricted competition, while a climate of fear and intimidation discouraged businesses from undertaking fresh investment.

Ramesh also accused the government of allowing regulatory bodies to fall under the influence of favoured interests and using investigative agencies to benefit a particular conglomerate. Those accusations were not accompanied by independently established findings in his remarks, and he did not provide supporting evidence for the specific claims.

He linked difficulties faced by smaller businesses to the trade deficit with China, alleging that its expansion had damaged large numbers of micro, small and medium enterprises. Ramesh also criticised demonetisation and the structure of the goods and services tax, arguing that the policies had imposed additional burdens on economic activity.

The Congress maintained that inflation, insufficient employment growth and restrained private investment reflected both the substance and implementation of the government's policies. Ramesh urged Modi to examine those choices instead of directing complaints towards industry leaders.

Modi's address extended beyond wages and recruitment. He urged companies to reduce dependence on imported pharmaceutical ingredients and specialised metal products by investing in domestic manufacturing capacity and technology. He also pressed businesses to improve product quality and compete more vigorously in overseas markets.

He called on industry to use trade agreements to develop export opportunities, saying the domestic market should not become a comfort zone. Businesses, he argued, needed to understand foreign customers, meet international standards and establish distribution networks that could support sustained exports and job creation.

The Prime Minister identified agriculture, food processing, engineering tools and machinery as areas where companies could expand production and overseas sales. He also invited businesses to submit proposals for further reforms, saying the government remained open to suggestions even when they identified shortcomings.

Supreme Court summons responses on judicial appointment rules

The Supreme Court has sought responses from the Centre and its Secretary General to a petition demanding completion of long-pending rules governing appointments to the higher judiciary.

A bench of Justices MM Sundresh and PB Varale issued notices on Wednesday, November 18, on a public interest petition filed by Lok Prahari, a Lucknow-based non-governmental organisation. The petition seeks finalisation of the revised Memorandum of Procedure (MoP) and greater public access to decisions taken by judicial Collegiums.

The organisation says the revision has remained unfinished for almost 11 years despite directions issued by a Constitution Bench in December 2015. It has asked the court to require the Union Ministry of Law and Justice to finalise the document within one month, following consultation with the Chief Justice of India.

The petition also seeks disclosure under the Right to Information Act of minutes relating to the selection of judges by the Supreme Court and High Court Collegiums. It argues that making the decision-making process accessible would improve transparency and accountability in appointments to constitutional courts.

The bench permitted Lok Prahari to submit an amended petition. Issuing notice does not amount to accepting the organisation's allegations or granting its requests. The government and the Supreme Court's administrative establishment have been asked to respond before the matter proceeds further.

During the hearing, Justice Sundresh raised the question of whether he should hear the case because he is a member of the Supreme Court Collegium. Senior advocate Sanjay Hegde, appearing for Lok Prahari, said he had no objection to the judge hearing the matter. The bench then proceeded to issue notice.

The hearing followed an earlier listing on November 2, when Justice PS Narasimha withdrew from the matter because he had appeared as an additional solicitor general in litigation concerning the judicial appointments procedure. The case was subsequently placed before a different bench.

The MoP sets out the administrative process for recommending, scrutinising and processing appointments and transfers involving judges of the Supreme Court and High Courts. The existing framework operates alongside the Collegium system, under which senior judges recommend candidates for appointment to the constitutional courts.

The dispute over revisions dates to the Supreme Court's October 2015 ruling striking down the National Judicial Appointments Commission, which Parliament had established to replace the Collegium. While retaining the judicial appointments system, the court acknowledged calls to improve its functioning, including its transparency and the criteria used in selecting judges.

On December 16, 2015, a Constitution Bench directed that the MoP be supplemented through a process involving the government and the Chief Justice of India, acting on the collective view of the four senior-most Supreme Court judges. The proposed revision has not been formally concluded amid differences between the executive and judiciary.

Lok Prahari contends that the prolonged delay has left unresolved deficiencies in the selection process. Its petition describes a lack of transparency and objectivity as harmful to the quality of judicial appointments and, consequently, to litigants seeking justice. Those assertions remain the petitioner's case, not findings made by the bench hearing the matter.

The organisation has asked that recommendations for judicial appointments reflect the unanimous view of the Collegium and take account of standards it considers necessary for impartial and independent judging. Its demands would require consideration of how existing appointment procedures operate and what information may lawfully be made public.

The petition also refers to efforts to obtain information about the status of the revised document. Lok Prahari says representations submitted to the Law Ministry in December 2015 were not acknowledged and that subsequent requests under the transparency law failed to provide satisfactory details of progress.

The court has not fixed a deadline for completing the revision at this stage. Nor has it directed disclosure of Collegium records. Both questions remain among the substantive issues raised by the petition for consideration after replies.

A further point raised in the petition concerns access to records of Collegium deliberations, rather than merely the recommendations eventually announced. The request therefore goes beyond completing an administrative document and seeks more extensive disclosure of how individual candidates are considered.

Lok Prahari's general secretary SN Shukla has pursued the issue through the organisation, while advocate Shashank Singh filed the petition. The bench's order allows changes to the pleadings before the respondents present their positions on the issues raised.

Supreme Court notifies parties over Ramlila protest challenge

The Supreme Court has sought responses from four political and student organisations over a petition by Delhi traders demanding that Ramlila Maidan lose its status as a designated protest venue, alleging demonstrations disrupt business and livelihoods.

A bench comprising Chief Justice Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana issued notices on Wednesday to the Congress, Cockroach Janata Party (CJP), All India Students Association (AISA) and Aam Aadmi Party (AAP). It also sought replies from the central government, Delhi government and Delhi Police Commissioner.

The court is expected to consider the traders' petition alongside proceedings concerning restrictions on demonstrations and the right to protest on November 27. The judges indicated that competing claims involving public assembly and commercial activity should be examined together rather than in isolation.

The petition was filed by the Delhi Kirana Committee and the Delhi Iron and Hardware Merchants' Association. The two bodies want the October 11 police order designating Ramlila Maidan as a protest venue overturned, arguing that the ground is surrounded by densely populated neighbourhoods and busy wholesale markets.

Senior advocate Mukul Rohatgi, representing the traders, told the bench that protests around central Delhi had interfered with commercial activity. He challenged the suitability of Ramlila Maidan, pointing to its location amid markets where businesses depend on uninterrupted customer access and the movement of goods.

The traders contend that demonstrations create road closures, congestion and access problems affecting not only shopkeepers but also vendors, employees, drivers and people living nearby. Their petition asks for safeguards covering the size and duration of gatherings, traffic management and continued access to residential areas, hospitals and public transport.

The bench had asked the petitioners on November 3 to include organisations responsible for the demonstrations as respondents, observing that affected parties should have an opportunity to be heard before orders were passed. Wednesday's notices followed the filing of the amended petition naming the four organisations.

The dispute places two sets of rights before the court. The organisations have been involved in protests concerning the Election Commission and restrictions on public demonstrations, while the traders maintain that their freedom to conduct business should not be disproportionately affected by protest arrangements.

Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, appearing for the Centre, supported considering the traders' concerns alongside petitions asserting the right to protest. He characterised the proceedings as involving competing rights of demonstrators, traders, workers and residents, making a combined hearing appropriate. The linked proceedings concern the extent to which authorities can regulate assemblies without extinguishing the ability of citizens and groups to demonstrate peacefully.

The court has not decided whether Ramlila Maidan should be removed from the list of approved demonstration venues. Issuing notices requires the respondents to address the allegations and legal demands; it does not establish that the named organisations acted unlawfully or caused the losses alleged by the petitioners.

Delhi Police designated Ramlila Maidan, Burari Ground and CBD Ground in east Delhi as protest venues through an order dated October 11, while removing Jantar Mantar from that list. The order followed recommendations from a committee constituted by the Union home ministry to examine alternative locations for demonstrations.

The traders' petition questions whether sufficient consideration was given to the effects on surrounding neighbourhoods and commerce before Ramlila Maidan was selected. It seeks a fresh assessment that takes account of nearby markets and arrangements for gatherings, rather than a blanket prohibition on peaceful political activity.

The challenge also follows a November 1 opposition rally at Ramlila Maidan organised by the Congress and its allies, which brought demonstrators to the area during the festive trading period. The traders argue that such events can affect sales at markets including Chawri Bazar, Chandni Chowk, Khari Baoli and Sadar Bazar.

The associations have claimed substantial financial losses from interrupted trade, particularly during weeks when seasonal demand supports a large share of annual turnover. Their estimates remain allegations before the court, and no judicial finding has established the value of any losses attributable to demonstrations. The organisations named in the amended petition have yet to present their responses to assertions before the bench.

The petitioners also seek clearer rules on potential damage to property and responsibility for maintaining access during public gatherings. Separate proceedings concerning police restrictions and alleged noncompliance with court directions are being handled within the wider group of protest-related cases.

US court routes Doval and Goel summons through Delhi

A US court has directed that summons for National Security Adviser Ajit Doval and former Research and Analysis Wing chief Samant Goel be transmitted to courts in Delhi in a civil lawsuit filed by Sikh separatist Gurpatwant Singh Pannun.

The US District Court for the Southern District of New York instructed its clerk to send documents by international mail or courier to three district courts, seeking their assistance in serving the two defendants. The order concerns the method of delivering legal papers, not a determination of the allegations.

Patiala House District Court has been identified for documents concerning Doval, while courts at Dwarka and Tis Hazari have been identified for Goel. The documents are intended for courts with jurisdiction over addresses where the defendants are believed to reside.

Sources familiar with the matter characterised the summons as non-binding and described the exercise as procedural. That assessment does not itself settle whether service would be recognised under applicable law. There has been no finding of liability against either official in the civil proceedings.

The transmission directive follows a November 9 ruling by District Judge Katherine Polk Failla authorising Pannun to attempt service through the Delhi courts. The judge accepted the proposed route after earlier attempts using the central authority under the Hague Service Convention were rejected.

The November 9 order required Pannun to submit a proposed package of documents by November 30, including the summons, supporting legal provisions, evidence of rejected service requests and a formal request for assistance. The court said its clerk would forward the materials after judicial approval.

The court's subsequent direction identifies the receiving courts and specifies mail or courier as the means of transmission. Whether the papers have been delivered to the defendants, or whether the Delhi courts have acted on the request, has not been established.

The case arises from Pannun's allegations of a conspiracy to assassinate him in New York. His September 2024 lawsuit names the government of India, Doval, Goel, Vikram Yadav, Nikhil Gupta and unidentified defendants. These are civil allegations contested by New Delhi, not findings made by the court.

The Ministry of External Affairs has dismissed the accusations as fabricated and malicious. Spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal said on November 11 that official communications concerning service of judicial documents must be channelled through the Ministry of Law and Justice, the designated authority for such matters.

The procedural disagreement centres on the Hague Convention, an international agreement governing service of civil and commercial judicial documents abroad. The New York court concluded that Article 19 permits methods allowed by the domestic law of the receiving country, notwithstanding the failure of Pannun's earlier attempts through the central authority.

Judge Failla considered Section 29 of India's Code of Civil Procedure, a 2009 government notification applying its provisions to courts in countries party to the convention, and rules allowing summons to be transmitted between courts. She found those provisions sufficient to authorise an attempt through the identified Delhi courts.

The ruling did not require the Delhi judiciary to decide the allegations. Nor did it establish that transmission to a court automatically amounts to completed service on an individual defendant. Further steps under the receiving jurisdiction's procedures remain distinct from the US court's authorisation.

The US State Department had transmitted papers concerning the lawsuit to the embassy of India in Washington. It informed the New York court that it took no position on Pannun's proposal to use the Delhi judiciary for service. The diplomatic transmission was not an endorsement of his claims.

Earlier, the judge rejected alternative proposals involving service by email, publication or diplomatic channels, citing restrictions under the convention and governing US law. The court's April ruling instead invited further submissions addressing the possibility of using courts in India.

The lawsuit is separate from federal criminal proceedings in the United States concerning an alleged murder-for-hire plot targeting Pannun. Allegations in the criminal case do not establish responsibility for any defendant in the civil case, which remains subject to its own procedural and evidentiary requirements.

The November 9 order also specified that Pannun's proposed package should include a record of the unsuccessful Hague Convention requests and a request that receiving courts provide documentation of any service carried out. Such records would allow the New York court to assess what procedural steps had occurred.

Shaina NC tears Thackeray photograph during Sena protest

A Shiv Sena protest against Sonia Gandhi’s memoir sparked a political confrontation in Mumbai on Wednesday after party spokesperson Shaina NC tore a sheet carrying a photograph of the party’s founder, Bal Thackeray.

The incident occurred as representatives of the Eknath Shinde-led Shiv Sena ripped pages from Belonging: A Journey of Love, accusing the Congress leader of insulting Hindutva ideologue V D Savarkar. Video footage showed Shaina tearing part of a photograph depicting Thackeray striking an effigy of former Union minister Mani Shankar Aiyar.

Shaina disputed allegations that she had damaged Thackeray’s image, insisting that she had targeted the depiction of Aiyar. Her explanation failed to prevent protests by the rival Shiv Sena (UBT), whose representatives accused the Shinde faction of disrespecting the founder whose legacy both parties claim.

The controversy reached the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation, where corporators from Shiv Sena (UBT) and the Maharashtra Navnirman Sena walked out of a general body meeting. Opposition representatives also protested at the civic headquarters, demanding action against Shaina.

Shiv Sena (UBT) leader Kishori Pednekar called for her resignation, while party MP Sanjay Raut accused the Shinde group of betraying its professed loyalty to Bal Thackeray. Congress leaders joined the criticism, arguing that tearing books was an unacceptable response to political disagreement.

Shaina rejected the accusation in a statement posted on X. “Show me where I have torn or disrespected Hindu Hriday Samrat Balasaheb Thackeray’s photograph,” she said, warning that she would take legal action against people spreading what she described as defamatory claims.

Deputy Chief Minister Eknath Shinde defended his colleague, saying she had shown him what she tore and that nobody in his party would insult Bal Thackeray. His intervention followed demands from opposition leaders that the party explain the incident.

The press conference had been intended to challenge Gandhi’s account of Savarkar and put pressure on Uddhav Thackeray, whose Shiv Sena (UBT) is allied with the Congress. The Shinde faction questioned how Uddhav could accept a copy of the memoir while maintaining his party’s longstanding regard for Savarkar.

Six spokespersons participated in the demonstration: Shaina, Sanjay Nirupam, Sheetal Mhatre, Sanjana Ghadi, Anand Dubey and Sushiben Shah. They displayed photographs contrasting Bal Thackeray’s opposition to Aiyar with Uddhav Thackeray’s acceptance of Gandhi’s book before tearing printed material.

One photograph recalled a 2004 protest during which Bal Thackeray struck an effigy of Aiyar with footwear over remarks concerning Savarkar. The sheet containing that photograph was caught up in Wednesday’s demonstration, and a colleague alerted Shaina as she tore it. She then set the damaged sheet aside.

Nirupam accused Gandhi of showing hostility towards Savarkar and called for the memoir to be banned. Other spokespersons demanded that publisher HarperCollins remove passages on pages 201 and 443, which they said offended supporters of the freedom fighter.

Gandhi’s memoir discusses Savarkar’s petitions for clemency to British colonial authorities and makes allegations about members of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh cooperating with the colonial administration. The Shiv Sena rejects her portrayal, describing it as an attack on Savarkar and Maharashtra’s political heritage.

Congress spokesperson Atul Londhe defended Gandhi’s account and said Savarkar’s mercy petitions were a matter of historical record. Congress leader Balasaheb Thorat argued that disagreement with a published work should be expressed through debate rather than destruction of its pages.

Congress leader Vijay Wadettiwar similarly criticised the demonstration, saying objections to a book could be presented democratically or answered through another publication. Nana Patole demanded police action against those involved in tearing the material, while Mumbai Congress leader Varsha Gaikwad accused the protesters of insulting Thackeray’s memory.

Shinde faction spokesperson Shital Mhatre challenged Uddhav Thackeray to clarify whether he accepted Gandhi’s comments about Savarkar. The faction also invoked his earlier support for honouring Savarkar with the Bharat Ratna, seeking to highlight differences between its rival’s historical positions and its present alliance with Congress.

The political dispute also drew a response from BJP leader Pravin Darekar, who said protesters should exercise greater care and apologise if they had accidentally damaged Thackeray’s photograph. His comments contrasted with the opposition’s demands for formal disciplinary action against Shaina.

The confrontation took place one day after the anniversary of Bal Thackeray’s death, a timing opposition leaders cited while criticising the protest. Separately, Shiv Sena (UBT) workers demonstrated outside the Shinde faction’s Balasaheb Bhavan office in Mumbai.

Rashidi challenges Javed Akhtar over remarks on Ram

Lyricist Javed Akhtar's description of Lord Ram as a moral ideal shared across religions has drawn criticism from cleric Maulana Sajid Rashidi, who questioned his motives and suggested that he change his name to Ram Pal.

Rashidi, president of the All India Imam Association, challenged Akhtar's comments on Tuesday, accusing the veteran screenwriter of invoking Ram to protect his commercial interests in the film industry. His allegations concerned Akhtar's intentions rather than any specific business transaction, and no evidence was offered to substantiate them.

Akhtar had told journalists in Mumbai that Ram represented more than a religious figure, describing him as an embodiment of morality, cultural sensibility and a way of living. He said the values associated with Ram extended beyond the boundaries of individual faiths.

“Many people may be angry with me, but the essence of Ram runs in the blood of every Indian, irrespective of religion,” Akhtar said. He added that although Ram was personified as an individual, he represented something much larger: a way of life.

Rashidi objected to those assertions, pointing to Akhtar's publicly stated atheism. He argued that someone who had repeatedly rejected religious belief should explain why he was now speaking so admiringly about Ram. The cleric presented Akhtar's words as an expression of religious devotion, although Akhtar had framed his remarks around ethics and cultural identity.

“I have a suggestion for him: change your name from Javed Akhtar to Ram Pal,” Rashidi said. He also suggested that Akhtar would gain greater acceptance among Hindu audiences by adopting such a position, a contention that reflected the cleric's personal interpretation of the writer's comments.

Rashidi further alleged that Akhtar's family connections to film production and songwriting influenced his public statements. He claimed that praise of religious figures could help artists retain audiences and sell their work. Those claims were not supported by independently established evidence linking the remarks to any commercial decision.

The exchange followed Akhtar's appearance at the launch of a music creators' report by the Indian Performing Right Society in Mumbai on Tuesday. Questions about the film Ramayana and Akhtar's lyrics for the 2004 film Swades prompted his observations about the cultural significance of Ram.

One question concerned the song Pal Pal Hai Bhaari, written by Akhtar for director Ashutosh Gowariker's Swades, starring Shah Rukh Khan. Its lyrics include the line “Mann se Raavan jo nikaale, Ram uske mann mein hai”, expressing the idea that overcoming evil within oneself makes room for Ram.

Akhtar explained the song's appeal by describing Ram as an ideal rather than merely a person. “Ram is not just a person, Ram is an ideal, a morality, Ram is a way of living,” he said, adding that the figure also represented certain aesthetic and ethical values that could touch people across religious identities.

The songwriter had initially responded with humour when asked why his words continued to resonate with listeners. “The simple explanation is that I'm a good writer, let's start from here,” he said, before elaborating on the meaning behind the song.

Congress politician Udit Raj, asked about Akhtar's remarks, said individuals were entitled to interpret religious texts from their own perspectives. Samajwadi Party MP Rajiv Rai likewise stressed the importance of allowing people to express differing views, while describing the Ramayana as sacred to Hindus. Neither politician endorsed Rashidi’s allegation that Akhtar had spoken for financial advantage, and defended differing interpretations.

The disagreement has also focused attention on the distinction between appreciating a religious tradition's ethical teachings and personally professing religious faith. Akhtar has openly identified as an atheist, and his comments at the Mumbai event did not include an announcement that he had changed his beliefs or adopted religious observance.

Akhtar, 81, also discussed Nitesh Tiwari's screen adaptation of the Ramayana. He said he had not watched the film, although his daughter, filmmaker Zoya Akhtar, had seen it and spoken positively about it. He joked that her praise carried weight because she was difficult to impress and rarely complimented his own work.

The adaptation features Ranbir Kapoor as Ram, Sai Pallavi as Sita and Yash as Ravana. Akhtar's discussion of the production arose alongside questions about how Hindi cinema draws upon established literary and cultural stories. He also remarked on the industry’s preference for broadly appealing formulas rather than adaptations of literary works.

US aircraft hit Iranian missile site amid blackout rumours

American fighter aircraft struck an Iranian missile launch site on Qeshm Island on Tuesday, as Washington cited threats to its forces and officials sought to dispel unfounded fears of a nationwide blackout in the United States.

A US military official said precision weapons targeted a facility operated by Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps on the island, near the Strait of Hormuz. The operation was conducted in self-defence following Iranian attacks against American personnel and military assets, the official said.

The strike followed a drone attack towards Bahrain, where Iran claimed it had hit an American radar installation. US Central Command disputed that account, saying air defences intercepted multiple Iranian drones without damage to equipment or injuries to personnel.

Central Command said the attempted attack was the third directed at US facilities in Bahrain within five days. Tehran had made similar claims about operations on Friday and Sunday, but American and Bahraini authorities said those attacks were also intercepted.

Ahmad Nafisi, deputy governor of Iran’s southern Hormozgan province, acknowledged the American strike on Qeshm Island but said residential, commercial and infrastructure areas had suffered no damage. The extent of any damage to the military installation was not independently established.

The exchange came as President Donald Trump warned Iran against any attack on Washington involving a chemical weapon or a radiological device. Speaking to journalists on arrival in Manila on Tuesday, Trump said his administration was taking intelligence suggesting a possible Iranian plot “very seriously”.

“If there is, they will pay a price the likes of which no country has ever paid before,” he said. The purported plot has not been established as an imminent threat, and officials have questioned whether Tehran has the intention or ability to carry it out.

White House spokesperson Lauren Bis said the administration was monitoring potential dangers but had identified no credible threat to the American homeland. Iran’s Foreign Ministry spokesman Esmaeil Baqaei rejected allegations that Tehran was considering such an attack, calling the allegations fabricated.

The military confrontation coincided with anxiety across the United States after interruptions to banking, communications and aviation services. Microsoft experienced widespread service problems last week, while a technical failure prompted the Federal Aviation Administration to impose a nationwide ground stop on Friday.

Several major banks reported transaction-processing difficulties on Monday, and United Airlines experienced disruption to its systems. A classified communications network used by the National Security Agency also suffered a disruption on Tuesday, which the agency attributed to scheduled maintenance.

The agency said some internal systems had been affected but essential national security capabilities remained operational. The White House said it had found no evidence that the various outages were linked to a cyberattack, despite speculation circulating online.

Trump dismissed suggestions that the interruptions signalled a broader emergency. Asked whether the failures concerned him, he replied: “No, it’s life.” Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy said investigators were examining an overloaded router linked to the aviation shutdown, while intelligence assessments had not indicated hacking.

Separate social media claims forecast a 90-day electricity blackout beginning on 17 November. There was no substantiated warning of such an event, and a video purporting to show Trump announcing it had been manipulated.

The Federal Emergency Management Agency had scheduled a nationwide Emergency Alert System test for Tuesday afternoon. The exercise involved television and radio broadcasts, not mobile telephone alerts, and required no action from the public. It was unrelated to any forecast electricity shutdown.

Confusion also surrounded a Pentagon programme intended to enable major military installations to operate independently if civilian electricity networks fail. The initiative focuses on military resilience against potential disruptions; it is not an announcement that civilian power supplies will be switched off.

Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin dismissed suggestions that Americans should stockpile supplies in anticipation of a prolonged shutdown. He said the claims spreading online were unfounded.

Meanwhile, Qatar’s Foreign Ministry spokesman Majed Al Ansari said mediation between Washington and Tehran was continuing and warned that escalating military operations endangered negotiations. He said Qatari representatives planned further discussions with Iranian officials over proposals under consideration.

Iran and Oman also discussed shipping security and diplomatic options for the Strait of Hormuz, their foreign ministers meeting in Muscat as commercial vessels continued to face uncertainty along the strategically important route, a waterway vital to global energy trade.