Loading…
Just in:
Loading latest syndicated reports…

Top stories

Updated continuously

Supreme Court summons responses on judicial appointment rules

The Supreme Court has sought responses from the Centre and its Secretary General to a petition demanding completion of long-pending rules governing appointments to the higher judiciary.

A bench of Justices MM Sundresh and PB Varale issued notices on Wednesday, November 18, on a public interest petition filed by Lok Prahari, a Lucknow-based non-governmental organisation. The petition seeks finalisation of the revised Memorandum of Procedure (MoP) and greater public access to decisions taken by judicial Collegiums.

The organisation says the revision has remained unfinished for almost 11 years despite directions issued by a Constitution Bench in December 2015. It has asked the court to require the Union Ministry of Law and Justice to finalise the document within one month, following consultation with the Chief Justice of India.

The petition also seeks disclosure under the Right to Information Act of minutes relating to the selection of judges by the Supreme Court and High Court Collegiums. It argues that making the decision-making process accessible would improve transparency and accountability in appointments to constitutional courts.

The bench permitted Lok Prahari to submit an amended petition. Issuing notice does not amount to accepting the organisation's allegations or granting its requests. The government and the Supreme Court's administrative establishment have been asked to respond before the matter proceeds further.

During the hearing, Justice Sundresh raised the question of whether he should hear the case because he is a member of the Supreme Court Collegium. Senior advocate Sanjay Hegde, appearing for Lok Prahari, said he had no objection to the judge hearing the matter. The bench then proceeded to issue notice.

The hearing followed an earlier listing on November 2, when Justice PS Narasimha withdrew from the matter because he had appeared as an additional solicitor general in litigation concerning the judicial appointments procedure. The case was subsequently placed before a different bench.

The MoP sets out the administrative process for recommending, scrutinising and processing appointments and transfers involving judges of the Supreme Court and High Courts. The existing framework operates alongside the Collegium system, under which senior judges recommend candidates for appointment to the constitutional courts.

The dispute over revisions dates to the Supreme Court's October 2015 ruling striking down the National Judicial Appointments Commission, which Parliament had established to replace the Collegium. While retaining the judicial appointments system, the court acknowledged calls to improve its functioning, including its transparency and the criteria used in selecting judges.

On December 16, 2015, a Constitution Bench directed that the MoP be supplemented through a process involving the government and the Chief Justice of India, acting on the collective view of the four senior-most Supreme Court judges. The proposed revision has not been formally concluded amid differences between the executive and judiciary.

Lok Prahari contends that the prolonged delay has left unresolved deficiencies in the selection process. Its petition describes a lack of transparency and objectivity as harmful to the quality of judicial appointments and, consequently, to litigants seeking justice. Those assertions remain the petitioner's case, not findings made by the bench hearing the matter.

The organisation has asked that recommendations for judicial appointments reflect the unanimous view of the Collegium and take account of standards it considers necessary for impartial and independent judging. Its demands would require consideration of how existing appointment procedures operate and what information may lawfully be made public.

The petition also refers to efforts to obtain information about the status of the revised document. Lok Prahari says representations submitted to the Law Ministry in December 2015 were not acknowledged and that subsequent requests under the transparency law failed to provide satisfactory details of progress.

The court has not fixed a deadline for completing the revision at this stage. Nor has it directed disclosure of Collegium records. Both questions remain among the substantive issues raised by the petition for consideration after replies.

A further point raised in the petition concerns access to records of Collegium deliberations, rather than merely the recommendations eventually announced. The request therefore goes beyond completing an administrative document and seeks more extensive disclosure of how individual candidates are considered.

Lok Prahari's general secretary SN Shukla has pursued the issue through the organisation, while advocate Shashank Singh filed the petition. The bench's order allows changes to the pleadings before the respondents present their positions on the issues raised.

Supreme Court notifies parties over Ramlila protest challenge

The Supreme Court has sought responses from four political and student organisations over a petition by Delhi traders demanding that Ramlila Maidan lose its status as a designated protest venue, alleging demonstrations disrupt business and livelihoods.

A bench comprising Chief Justice Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana issued notices on Wednesday to the Congress, Cockroach Janata Party (CJP), All India Students Association (AISA) and Aam Aadmi Party (AAP). It also sought replies from the central government, Delhi government and Delhi Police Commissioner.

The court is expected to consider the traders' petition alongside proceedings concerning restrictions on demonstrations and the right to protest on November 27. The judges indicated that competing claims involving public assembly and commercial activity should be examined together rather than in isolation.

The petition was filed by the Delhi Kirana Committee and the Delhi Iron and Hardware Merchants' Association. The two bodies want the October 11 police order designating Ramlila Maidan as a protest venue overturned, arguing that the ground is surrounded by densely populated neighbourhoods and busy wholesale markets.

Senior advocate Mukul Rohatgi, representing the traders, told the bench that protests around central Delhi had interfered with commercial activity. He challenged the suitability of Ramlila Maidan, pointing to its location amid markets where businesses depend on uninterrupted customer access and the movement of goods.

The traders contend that demonstrations create road closures, congestion and access problems affecting not only shopkeepers but also vendors, employees, drivers and people living nearby. Their petition asks for safeguards covering the size and duration of gatherings, traffic management and continued access to residential areas, hospitals and public transport.

The bench had asked the petitioners on November 3 to include organisations responsible for the demonstrations as respondents, observing that affected parties should have an opportunity to be heard before orders were passed. Wednesday's notices followed the filing of the amended petition naming the four organisations.

The dispute places two sets of rights before the court. The organisations have been involved in protests concerning the Election Commission and restrictions on public demonstrations, while the traders maintain that their freedom to conduct business should not be disproportionately affected by protest arrangements.

Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, appearing for the Centre, supported considering the traders' concerns alongside petitions asserting the right to protest. He characterised the proceedings as involving competing rights of demonstrators, traders, workers and residents, making a combined hearing appropriate. The linked proceedings concern the extent to which authorities can regulate assemblies without extinguishing the ability of citizens and groups to demonstrate peacefully.

The court has not decided whether Ramlila Maidan should be removed from the list of approved demonstration venues. Issuing notices requires the respondents to address the allegations and legal demands; it does not establish that the named organisations acted unlawfully or caused the losses alleged by the petitioners.

Delhi Police designated Ramlila Maidan, Burari Ground and CBD Ground in east Delhi as protest venues through an order dated October 11, while removing Jantar Mantar from that list. The order followed recommendations from a committee constituted by the Union home ministry to examine alternative locations for demonstrations.

The traders' petition questions whether sufficient consideration was given to the effects on surrounding neighbourhoods and commerce before Ramlila Maidan was selected. It seeks a fresh assessment that takes account of nearby markets and arrangements for gatherings, rather than a blanket prohibition on peaceful political activity.

The challenge also follows a November 1 opposition rally at Ramlila Maidan organised by the Congress and its allies, which brought demonstrators to the area during the festive trading period. The traders argue that such events can affect sales at markets including Chawri Bazar, Chandni Chowk, Khari Baoli and Sadar Bazar.

The associations have claimed substantial financial losses from interrupted trade, particularly during weeks when seasonal demand supports a large share of annual turnover. Their estimates remain allegations before the court, and no judicial finding has established the value of any losses attributable to demonstrations. The organisations named in the amended petition have yet to present their responses to assertions before the bench.

The petitioners also seek clearer rules on potential damage to property and responsibility for maintaining access during public gatherings. Separate proceedings concerning police restrictions and alleged noncompliance with court directions are being handled within the wider group of protest-related cases.

US court routes Doval and Goel summons through Delhi

A US court has directed that summons for National Security Adviser Ajit Doval and former Research and Analysis Wing chief Samant Goel be transmitted to courts in Delhi in a civil lawsuit filed by Sikh separatist Gurpatwant Singh Pannun.

The US District Court for the Southern District of New York instructed its clerk to send documents by international mail or courier to three district courts, seeking their assistance in serving the two defendants. The order concerns the method of delivering legal papers, not a determination of the allegations.

Patiala House District Court has been identified for documents concerning Doval, while courts at Dwarka and Tis Hazari have been identified for Goel. The documents are intended for courts with jurisdiction over addresses where the defendants are believed to reside.

Sources familiar with the matter characterised the summons as non-binding and described the exercise as procedural. That assessment does not itself settle whether service would be recognised under applicable law. There has been no finding of liability against either official in the civil proceedings.

The transmission directive follows a November 9 ruling by District Judge Katherine Polk Failla authorising Pannun to attempt service through the Delhi courts. The judge accepted the proposed route after earlier attempts using the central authority under the Hague Service Convention were rejected.

The November 9 order required Pannun to submit a proposed package of documents by November 30, including the summons, supporting legal provisions, evidence of rejected service requests and a formal request for assistance. The court said its clerk would forward the materials after judicial approval.

The court's subsequent direction identifies the receiving courts and specifies mail or courier as the means of transmission. Whether the papers have been delivered to the defendants, or whether the Delhi courts have acted on the request, has not been established.

The case arises from Pannun's allegations of a conspiracy to assassinate him in New York. His September 2024 lawsuit names the government of India, Doval, Goel, Vikram Yadav, Nikhil Gupta and unidentified defendants. These are civil allegations contested by New Delhi, not findings made by the court.

The Ministry of External Affairs has dismissed the accusations as fabricated and malicious. Spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal said on November 11 that official communications concerning service of judicial documents must be channelled through the Ministry of Law and Justice, the designated authority for such matters.

The procedural disagreement centres on the Hague Convention, an international agreement governing service of civil and commercial judicial documents abroad. The New York court concluded that Article 19 permits methods allowed by the domestic law of the receiving country, notwithstanding the failure of Pannun's earlier attempts through the central authority.

Judge Failla considered Section 29 of India's Code of Civil Procedure, a 2009 government notification applying its provisions to courts in countries party to the convention, and rules allowing summons to be transmitted between courts. She found those provisions sufficient to authorise an attempt through the identified Delhi courts.

The ruling did not require the Delhi judiciary to decide the allegations. Nor did it establish that transmission to a court automatically amounts to completed service on an individual defendant. Further steps under the receiving jurisdiction's procedures remain distinct from the US court's authorisation.

The US State Department had transmitted papers concerning the lawsuit to the embassy of India in Washington. It informed the New York court that it took no position on Pannun's proposal to use the Delhi judiciary for service. The diplomatic transmission was not an endorsement of his claims.

Earlier, the judge rejected alternative proposals involving service by email, publication or diplomatic channels, citing restrictions under the convention and governing US law. The court's April ruling instead invited further submissions addressing the possibility of using courts in India.

The lawsuit is separate from federal criminal proceedings in the United States concerning an alleged murder-for-hire plot targeting Pannun. Allegations in the criminal case do not establish responsibility for any defendant in the civil case, which remains subject to its own procedural and evidentiary requirements.

The November 9 order also specified that Pannun's proposed package should include a record of the unsuccessful Hague Convention requests and a request that receiving courts provide documentation of any service carried out. Such records would allow the New York court to assess what procedural steps had occurred.

Shaina NC tears Thackeray photograph during Sena protest

A Shiv Sena protest against Sonia Gandhi’s memoir sparked a political confrontation in Mumbai on Wednesday after party spokesperson Shaina NC tore a sheet carrying a photograph of the party’s founder, Bal Thackeray.

The incident occurred as representatives of the Eknath Shinde-led Shiv Sena ripped pages from Belonging: A Journey of Love, accusing the Congress leader of insulting Hindutva ideologue V D Savarkar. Video footage showed Shaina tearing part of a photograph depicting Thackeray striking an effigy of former Union minister Mani Shankar Aiyar.

Shaina disputed allegations that she had damaged Thackeray’s image, insisting that she had targeted the depiction of Aiyar. Her explanation failed to prevent protests by the rival Shiv Sena (UBT), whose representatives accused the Shinde faction of disrespecting the founder whose legacy both parties claim.

The controversy reached the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation, where corporators from Shiv Sena (UBT) and the Maharashtra Navnirman Sena walked out of a general body meeting. Opposition representatives also protested at the civic headquarters, demanding action against Shaina.

Shiv Sena (UBT) leader Kishori Pednekar called for her resignation, while party MP Sanjay Raut accused the Shinde group of betraying its professed loyalty to Bal Thackeray. Congress leaders joined the criticism, arguing that tearing books was an unacceptable response to political disagreement.

Shaina rejected the accusation in a statement posted on X. “Show me where I have torn or disrespected Hindu Hriday Samrat Balasaheb Thackeray’s photograph,” she said, warning that she would take legal action against people spreading what she described as defamatory claims.

Deputy Chief Minister Eknath Shinde defended his colleague, saying she had shown him what she tore and that nobody in his party would insult Bal Thackeray. His intervention followed demands from opposition leaders that the party explain the incident.

The press conference had been intended to challenge Gandhi’s account of Savarkar and put pressure on Uddhav Thackeray, whose Shiv Sena (UBT) is allied with the Congress. The Shinde faction questioned how Uddhav could accept a copy of the memoir while maintaining his party’s longstanding regard for Savarkar.

Six spokespersons participated in the demonstration: Shaina, Sanjay Nirupam, Sheetal Mhatre, Sanjana Ghadi, Anand Dubey and Sushiben Shah. They displayed photographs contrasting Bal Thackeray’s opposition to Aiyar with Uddhav Thackeray’s acceptance of Gandhi’s book before tearing printed material.

One photograph recalled a 2004 protest during which Bal Thackeray struck an effigy of Aiyar with footwear over remarks concerning Savarkar. The sheet containing that photograph was caught up in Wednesday’s demonstration, and a colleague alerted Shaina as she tore it. She then set the damaged sheet aside.

Nirupam accused Gandhi of showing hostility towards Savarkar and called for the memoir to be banned. Other spokespersons demanded that publisher HarperCollins remove passages on pages 201 and 443, which they said offended supporters of the freedom fighter.

Gandhi’s memoir discusses Savarkar’s petitions for clemency to British colonial authorities and makes allegations about members of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh cooperating with the colonial administration. The Shiv Sena rejects her portrayal, describing it as an attack on Savarkar and Maharashtra’s political heritage.

Congress spokesperson Atul Londhe defended Gandhi’s account and said Savarkar’s mercy petitions were a matter of historical record. Congress leader Balasaheb Thorat argued that disagreement with a published work should be expressed through debate rather than destruction of its pages.

Congress leader Vijay Wadettiwar similarly criticised the demonstration, saying objections to a book could be presented democratically or answered through another publication. Nana Patole demanded police action against those involved in tearing the material, while Mumbai Congress leader Varsha Gaikwad accused the protesters of insulting Thackeray’s memory.

Shinde faction spokesperson Shital Mhatre challenged Uddhav Thackeray to clarify whether he accepted Gandhi’s comments about Savarkar. The faction also invoked his earlier support for honouring Savarkar with the Bharat Ratna, seeking to highlight differences between its rival’s historical positions and its present alliance with Congress.

The political dispute also drew a response from BJP leader Pravin Darekar, who said protesters should exercise greater care and apologise if they had accidentally damaged Thackeray’s photograph. His comments contrasted with the opposition’s demands for formal disciplinary action against Shaina.

The confrontation took place one day after the anniversary of Bal Thackeray’s death, a timing opposition leaders cited while criticising the protest. Separately, Shiv Sena (UBT) workers demonstrated outside the Shinde faction’s Balasaheb Bhavan office in Mumbai.

Rashidi challenges Javed Akhtar over remarks on Ram

Lyricist Javed Akhtar's description of Lord Ram as a moral ideal shared across religions has drawn criticism from cleric Maulana Sajid Rashidi, who questioned his motives and suggested that he change his name to Ram Pal.

Rashidi, president of the All India Imam Association, challenged Akhtar's comments on Tuesday, accusing the veteran screenwriter of invoking Ram to protect his commercial interests in the film industry. His allegations concerned Akhtar's intentions rather than any specific business transaction, and no evidence was offered to substantiate them.

Akhtar had told journalists in Mumbai that Ram represented more than a religious figure, describing him as an embodiment of morality, cultural sensibility and a way of living. He said the values associated with Ram extended beyond the boundaries of individual faiths.

“Many people may be angry with me, but the essence of Ram runs in the blood of every Indian, irrespective of religion,” Akhtar said. He added that although Ram was personified as an individual, he represented something much larger: a way of life.

Rashidi objected to those assertions, pointing to Akhtar's publicly stated atheism. He argued that someone who had repeatedly rejected religious belief should explain why he was now speaking so admiringly about Ram. The cleric presented Akhtar's words as an expression of religious devotion, although Akhtar had framed his remarks around ethics and cultural identity.

“I have a suggestion for him: change your name from Javed Akhtar to Ram Pal,” Rashidi said. He also suggested that Akhtar would gain greater acceptance among Hindu audiences by adopting such a position, a contention that reflected the cleric's personal interpretation of the writer's comments.

Rashidi further alleged that Akhtar's family connections to film production and songwriting influenced his public statements. He claimed that praise of religious figures could help artists retain audiences and sell their work. Those claims were not supported by independently established evidence linking the remarks to any commercial decision.

The exchange followed Akhtar's appearance at the launch of a music creators' report by the Indian Performing Right Society in Mumbai on Tuesday. Questions about the film Ramayana and Akhtar's lyrics for the 2004 film Swades prompted his observations about the cultural significance of Ram.

One question concerned the song Pal Pal Hai Bhaari, written by Akhtar for director Ashutosh Gowariker's Swades, starring Shah Rukh Khan. Its lyrics include the line “Mann se Raavan jo nikaale, Ram uske mann mein hai”, expressing the idea that overcoming evil within oneself makes room for Ram.

Akhtar explained the song's appeal by describing Ram as an ideal rather than merely a person. “Ram is not just a person, Ram is an ideal, a morality, Ram is a way of living,” he said, adding that the figure also represented certain aesthetic and ethical values that could touch people across religious identities.

The songwriter had initially responded with humour when asked why his words continued to resonate with listeners. “The simple explanation is that I'm a good writer, let's start from here,” he said, before elaborating on the meaning behind the song.

Congress politician Udit Raj, asked about Akhtar's remarks, said individuals were entitled to interpret religious texts from their own perspectives. Samajwadi Party MP Rajiv Rai likewise stressed the importance of allowing people to express differing views, while describing the Ramayana as sacred to Hindus. Neither politician endorsed Rashidi’s allegation that Akhtar had spoken for financial advantage, and defended differing interpretations.

The disagreement has also focused attention on the distinction between appreciating a religious tradition's ethical teachings and personally professing religious faith. Akhtar has openly identified as an atheist, and his comments at the Mumbai event did not include an announcement that he had changed his beliefs or adopted religious observance.

Akhtar, 81, also discussed Nitesh Tiwari's screen adaptation of the Ramayana. He said he had not watched the film, although his daughter, filmmaker Zoya Akhtar, had seen it and spoken positively about it. He joked that her praise carried weight because she was difficult to impress and rarely complimented his own work.

The adaptation features Ranbir Kapoor as Ram, Sai Pallavi as Sita and Yash as Ravana. Akhtar's discussion of the production arose alongside questions about how Hindi cinema draws upon established literary and cultural stories. He also remarked on the industry’s preference for broadly appealing formulas rather than adaptations of literary works.

US aircraft hit Iranian missile site amid blackout rumours

American fighter aircraft struck an Iranian missile launch site on Qeshm Island on Tuesday, as Washington cited threats to its forces and officials sought to dispel unfounded fears of a nationwide blackout in the United States.

A US military official said precision weapons targeted a facility operated by Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps on the island, near the Strait of Hormuz. The operation was conducted in self-defence following Iranian attacks against American personnel and military assets, the official said.

The strike followed a drone attack towards Bahrain, where Iran claimed it had hit an American radar installation. US Central Command disputed that account, saying air defences intercepted multiple Iranian drones without damage to equipment or injuries to personnel.

Central Command said the attempted attack was the third directed at US facilities in Bahrain within five days. Tehran had made similar claims about operations on Friday and Sunday, but American and Bahraini authorities said those attacks were also intercepted.

Ahmad Nafisi, deputy governor of Iran’s southern Hormozgan province, acknowledged the American strike on Qeshm Island but said residential, commercial and infrastructure areas had suffered no damage. The extent of any damage to the military installation was not independently established.

The exchange came as President Donald Trump warned Iran against any attack on Washington involving a chemical weapon or a radiological device. Speaking to journalists on arrival in Manila on Tuesday, Trump said his administration was taking intelligence suggesting a possible Iranian plot “very seriously”.

“If there is, they will pay a price the likes of which no country has ever paid before,” he said. The purported plot has not been established as an imminent threat, and officials have questioned whether Tehran has the intention or ability to carry it out.

White House spokesperson Lauren Bis said the administration was monitoring potential dangers but had identified no credible threat to the American homeland. Iran’s Foreign Ministry spokesman Esmaeil Baqaei rejected allegations that Tehran was considering such an attack, calling the allegations fabricated.

The military confrontation coincided with anxiety across the United States after interruptions to banking, communications and aviation services. Microsoft experienced widespread service problems last week, while a technical failure prompted the Federal Aviation Administration to impose a nationwide ground stop on Friday.

Several major banks reported transaction-processing difficulties on Monday, and United Airlines experienced disruption to its systems. A classified communications network used by the National Security Agency also suffered a disruption on Tuesday, which the agency attributed to scheduled maintenance.

The agency said some internal systems had been affected but essential national security capabilities remained operational. The White House said it had found no evidence that the various outages were linked to a cyberattack, despite speculation circulating online.

Trump dismissed suggestions that the interruptions signalled a broader emergency. Asked whether the failures concerned him, he replied: “No, it’s life.” Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy said investigators were examining an overloaded router linked to the aviation shutdown, while intelligence assessments had not indicated hacking.

Separate social media claims forecast a 90-day electricity blackout beginning on 17 November. There was no substantiated warning of such an event, and a video purporting to show Trump announcing it had been manipulated.

The Federal Emergency Management Agency had scheduled a nationwide Emergency Alert System test for Tuesday afternoon. The exercise involved television and radio broadcasts, not mobile telephone alerts, and required no action from the public. It was unrelated to any forecast electricity shutdown.

Confusion also surrounded a Pentagon programme intended to enable major military installations to operate independently if civilian electricity networks fail. The initiative focuses on military resilience against potential disruptions; it is not an announcement that civilian power supplies will be switched off.

Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin dismissed suggestions that Americans should stockpile supplies in anticipation of a prolonged shutdown. He said the claims spreading online were unfounded.

Meanwhile, Qatar’s Foreign Ministry spokesman Majed Al Ansari said mediation between Washington and Tehran was continuing and warned that escalating military operations endangered negotiations. He said Qatari representatives planned further discussions with Iranian officials over proposals under consideration.

Iran and Oman also discussed shipping security and diplomatic options for the Strait of Hormuz, their foreign ministers meeting in Muscat as commercial vessels continued to face uncertainty along the strategically important route, a waterway vital to global energy trade.

Supreme Court sustains Azam Khan conviction stay, extends relief

The Supreme Court on Tuesday dismissed the Uttar Pradesh government's challenge to a stay on Samajwadi Party leader Azam Khan's conviction in a forged birth certificate case and extended the same protection to his wife and son.

A bench of Justices Dipankar Datta and Sheel Nagu upheld the Allahabad High Court's May 24, 2024, decision concerning Khan while allowing separate appeals by his wife, Tazeen Fatma, and son, Mohammad Abdullah Azam Khan. Their convictions will also remain suspended while their criminal revision petitions are pending before the High Court.

The ruling removes the distinction the High Court had drawn between the three family members. Although it suspended all three prison sentences and granted bail, the High Court had stayed only Azam Khan's conviction, declining equivalent relief to his wife and son.

The Supreme Court held that the High Court had not adequately explained why people convicted in the same alleged conspiracy, on substantially identical evidence, should receive different interim treatment. It described that unequal approach as a violation of the principle of parity and an error of jurisdiction.

The judgment invoked constitutional guarantees of equality and personal dignity, noting that arbitrary differences in the treatment of similarly placed defendants can have consequences while their challenges to convictions remain undecided.

The judges also rejected the state government's contention that the High Court had improperly granted Azam Khan relief beyond what he had sought. The record showed that applications seeking stays of conviction had been filed separately, alongside requests to suspend the sentences.

Additional Solicitor General K M Nataraj, appearing for Uttar Pradesh, argued that the High Court had failed to give distinct reasons for suspending Khan's conviction. Senior advocate Kapil Sibal represented the three family members and contested the state's objections.

The Supreme Court found the High Court's reasoning sufficient, pointing to its consideration of Khan's period in custody, age and the absence of direct evidence that he personally forged signatures in municipal registers. It held there was no compelling ground to interfere with that exercise of discretion under Article 136 of the Constitution.

The bench nevertheless emphasised that staying a conviction is an exceptional measure, different from suspending a prison sentence. Suspension of sentence postpones punishment pending judicial review, whereas a stay of conviction temporarily halts the legal consequences flowing from a finding of guilt.

The judgment said such discretion must be exercised consistently, while taking account of the consequences for individuals and the public interest. Courts could distinguish between co-convicts where the evidence justified it, but any material difference had to be clearly identified and explained.

The judges also rejected the idea that electoral considerations alone could justify an order staying a conviction. They said statutory judicial powers could not be employed merely to accommodate political ambitions or election timetables.

The decision does not overturn the underlying convictions or decide whether the accused committed the offences. Those questions remain before the Allahabad High Court, which has been directed to determine the pending revision petitions independently and as expeditiously as possible, without being influenced by the Supreme Court's observations.

A Rampur trial court convicted the three in October 2023 and sentenced them to seven years' imprisonment in a case involving allegations of cheating, forgery and criminal conspiracy. An appellate court affirmed the convictions in December that year, after which the family sought relief before the High Court.

The prosecution case arose from a complaint concerning two birth certificates for Abdullah Azam Khan. Investigators alleged that documents issued in Rampur and Lucknow recorded conflicting dates and places of birth. The allegations formed the basis of a case registered at Ganj police station in Rampur in January 2019.

The Supreme Court noted that the prosecution relied on a common allegation of conspiracy and the same disputed documents against all three defendants. It found no separately attributed act of physically forging documents by Fatma or Abdullah beyond their alleged roles as co-conspirators and beneficiaries.

The bench observed that a conviction can affect reputation and personal dignity while legal proceedings remain unresolved. It said courts considering interim relief must balance potential irreversible harm against the importance of preserving the authority of criminal convictions until they are set aside.

The parties agreed to cooperate with the High Court bench hearing their revision petitions to facilitate an early disposal of those proceedings.

Modi retrieves flag marker during Manila Quad photograph

Prime Minister Narendra Modi picked up a floor marker bearing India's national flag during a photograph with Quad leaders in Manila on Tuesday, drawing a brief response from US President Donald Trump before the four leaders began their summit.

Video of the gathering showed Modi bending to retrieve a small card displaying the Tricolour from the carpet where the leaders were assembling for photographs. The card appeared to mark his designated standing position. Modi put it in his pocket rather than leave it on the floor.

“I cannot put the flag on the floor,” Modi said as he collected the marker. Trump, standing nearby, replied, “Save it.” The exchange took place in front of cameras as the leaders prepared for their meeting on the sidelines of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations summit in the Philippine capital.

Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese and Japanese Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi joined Modi and Trump for the photograph. The footage circulated on social media after the event, drawing attention to an unscripted moment during the otherwise formal diplomatic engagement.

The government's MyGov India account shared the footage on Tuesday, describing the gesture as an expression of respect for the national flag. The video showed a position marker bearing the flag rather than a full-sized fabric flag, a distinction reflected in photographs of the gathering.

The Manila incident echoed a similar episode at the BRICS summit in Johannesburg in August 2023, when Modi removed a marker displaying the national flag from the floor before a group photograph. Both episodes involved markers used by event organisers to position participating leaders, rather than flags displayed on poles. Neither incident interrupted the scheduled meetings, and the Manila exchange lasted only a few seconds before the leaders resumed their preparations.

The four leaders subsequently met for the first Quad summit at leaders' level since 2024 and the first attended by Trump during his second term. Their discussions focused on maritime security, critical supply chains, emerging technology and closer cooperation across the Indo-Pacific.

A joint statement issued on November 17 said the leaders opposed unilateral attempts to alter the regional status quo through force or coercion. They also expressed concern about economic coercion, including arbitrary export restrictions, and reaffirmed support for freedom of navigation and overflight.

The summit announced plans for an inaugural Quad Business Leaders' Forum in early 2027, intended to bring together businesses, government representatives and policy specialists from the four countries. The leaders also endorsed an initiative to widen access to artificial intelligence technologies and technical assistance across the region.

Another agreement provided for closer maritime surveillance and information sharing. Under the Indo-Pacific Maritime Surveillance Collaboration, patrol aircraft from the four countries are scheduled to participate in a maritime exercise in 2027, the first such activity involving those aircraft in a Quad setting.

The leaders also agreed to strengthen cybersecurity cooperation, undersea cable resilience and counterterrorism coordination. Australia's contribution to a connectivity partnership is to expand into electricity cables, while planned subsea cable projects in the Indian Ocean were welcomed as measures to improve regional connectivity.

Addressing the meeting, Modi called the Quad a “constructive and trusted partnership” and said its work should offer practical solutions in maritime security, supply chains, technology and disaster response. He urged the leaders to establish concrete objectives for the next stage of cooperation.

Trump praised Modi during the meeting, calling him a friend and a respected leader. He described relations between Washington and New Delhi as outstanding, remarks delivered separately from his brief response to the flag-marker incident during the photograph.

The meeting took place while Manila hosted regional leaders for ASEAN-related discussions. The Philippines is not a member of the Quad, which brings together India, the United States, Australia and Japan. The gathering provided an opportunity for the four leaders to meet alongside the wider diplomatic programme.

Modi also recalled Manila's connection with the grouping, noting that officials from the four countries met in the city in 2007 and that their consultations resumed there in 2017. He said the foreign ministers had held five meetings since January 2025, indicating continued engagement despite the interval between leaders' summits.

Following the photograph, Modi gestured towards the meeting room and asked, “Shall we move?”, while Trump and Albanese were still conversing. The leaders then proceeded with the scheduled discussions.

Supreme Court directs Raut to explain further posts

The Supreme Court has directed Shiv Sena (UBT) MP Sanjay Raut to explain further social media posts about the judiciary, while reminding him that an experienced parliamentarian must exercise restraint in his language.

A bench of Justices Aravind Kumar and Vipul M Pancholi issued the direction on Tuesday during criminal contempt proceedings brought by the Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA) over remarks concerning Chief Justice of India Surya Kant and the courts. Raut appeared personally, while journalist Nikhil Wagle, also named in the proceedings, attended virtually.

The judges asked both men to file additional affidavits addressing the statements cited against them and ordered them to attend the next hearing in person on December 8. The court did not decide whether either respondent had committed contempt.

Addressing Raut, Justice Kumar said he was a seasoned politician whose speeches the judge had followed since his days as a lawyer. As an experienced parliamentarian, Raut should understand the restraint expected in public statements, the judge observed.

The bench also questioned whether Raut's apology adequately addressed his conduct. Justice Kumar said an apology in a matter of this nature should come from the heart rather than the mind, indicating that the court wanted a fuller explanation before considering his position.

SCBA president and senior advocate Pradeep Rai argued that Raut had continued posting material critical of the judiciary after expressing regret. Rai cited statements alleging that the Bharatiya Janata Party controlled the judiciary, investigating agencies and the Election Commission, along with a post depicting a fire at Albania's Supreme Court.

Rai submitted that the image and accompanying remarks carried an implied reference to India's Supreme Court. He also questioned why Raut's earlier affidavit did not address those posts. The allegations were made by the association and were not findings recorded against Raut by the bench.

Raut's counsel said he was not defending the remarks and maintained that his client had tendered an unconditional apology and undertaken not to repeat the conduct. Counsel agreed that a further affidavit could be submitted and asked the judges to consider Raut's treatment for cancer and heart ailments.

The court nevertheless declined a request to excuse Raut from attending the next hearing. Its direction for a further affidavit leaves him an opportunity to respond specifically to the additional posts relied upon by the association.

The bench separately examined Wagle's position after senior advocate Indira Jaising submitted that the journalist had deleted the offending post, acknowledged his mistake and apologised unconditionally to the Chief Justice and the Supreme Court. She requested that he be discharged from the proceedings.

Jaising argued that Wagle was not attempting to justify his language. She also raised the legal distinction between an offensive remark directed at a judge and conduct amounting to criminal contempt, urging the bench to assess the context rather than treating every insult as contempt automatically.

The judges required Wagle to provide a further affidavit addressing the precise wording of his social media post. Justice Kumar observed that journalists have responsibilities associated with their position as members of the fourth estate. The court also directed Wagle to attend physically on December 8, notwithstanding his counsel's request for exemption.

The association initiated the case after remarks made following Chief Justice Surya Kant's decision not to meet an opposition delegation seeking to discuss concerns about the functioning of the Election Commission. The Chief Justice had indicated that such grievances should be brought before the court through appropriate legal proceedings.

The SCBA sought action over Wagle's abusive online message and statements attributed to Raut concerning judges and alleged political associations. Those statements included a claim about judges playing badminton with political figures in London, which the association described as false. The proceedings concern whether the disputed expressions cross the legal threshold for criminal contempt.

Attorney General R Venkataramani granted the consent required for the SCBA to pursue the petition under Section 15 of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971. The court issued notices to the respondents in October and subsequently required their participation in the hearing.

After hearing the parties, the matter is listed for December 8 at 2 pm, when the court is expected to consider the supplementary affidavits. Both respondents have been instructed to attend personally rather than through video conferencing. The earlier hearing had permitted Wagle to participate remotely.

Shirsat signals fresh Maharashtra political realignment under Operation Tiger-3

Maharashtra minister Sanjay Shirsat has endorsed predictions of another political realignment under the banner of Operation Tiger-3, claiming that several leaders and party office-bearers are in contact with Deputy Chief Minister Eknath Shinde's Shiv Sena faction.

Speaking in Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar on Monday, Shirsat supported fellow minister Uday Samant's assertion that the exercise could take place soon. He said Shinde would decide what action to take and when, stopping short of identifying the politicians involved or announcing any formal move.

“What Minister Uday Samant has said is true. Many leaders and office-bearers are in touch with us, some directly,” Shirsat said. He added that Shinde was known for taking decisions at the appropriate time and predicted that people would witness an Operation Tiger-3 “of a different kind”.

The remarks have revived discussion about possible defections from Shiv Sena (Uddhav Balasaheb Thackeray), the rival faction led by former chief minister Uddhav Thackeray. Neither Shirsat nor Samant publicly provided a list of prospective entrants, evidence of an agreed transfer or a date for any announcement. Their statements therefore remain indications of political intent rather than confirmation of defections. The ministers did not clarify whether the proposed operation concerned elected representatives or party functionaries, a distinction for assessing consequences.

Samant had said on Sunday that Operation Tiger would take place but declined to disclose its timing. He invoked the secrecy surrounding earlier shifts within Maharashtra politics to explain why he would not specify a date or hour for the proposed exercise.

The term Operation Tiger has been used in political discussions surrounding attempts to attract politicians from the Thackeray-led organisation to the Shinde camp. The latest comments do not establish whether the proposed initiative would involve legislators, parliamentarians, organisational officials or a combination of groups, nor whether any negotiations have reached an agreement.

The prospect has drawn a sharp response from opposition leaders. Aaditya Thackeray, a Shiv Sena (UBT) legislator and Uddhav Thackeray's son, challenged the Shinde faction to address conditions in Maharashtra instead of concentrating on political defections. He accused those who switched sides of placing power and personal advantage ahead of their former party, allegations that reflect the opposition's position rather than established findings.

Aaditya also cited difficulties faced by farmers, students and communities experiencing water shortages as issues requiring the government's attention. His criticism sought to redirect the argument from party arithmetic to public administration, while Shinde's colleagues maintained that contacts with other political figures were continuing.

Shiv Sena (UBT) leader Sanjay Raut also dismissed the suggestion that his party faced an imminent setback. Responding to Samant's comments, he questioned the political independence of the ruling faction and suggested its leaders should concentrate on their own organisation. The exchange demonstrated the continuing hostility between the two groups, but did not resolve whether any lawmakers intended to change allegiance.

Shinde heads one of the principal parties in Maharashtra's governing Mahayuti alliance alongside the Bharatiya Janata Party. His group and the Thackeray-led Shiv Sena have remained separate since the party split in 2022. That division explains why claims of further movement between the factions carry significance for their competing claims to political support and organisational strength.

Speculation also accompanied a meeting between Shinde and Union Home Minister Amit Shah in Pune on Monday. No verified announcement from that meeting established a connection with Operation Tiger-3, and the existence of talks between senior alliance leaders does not itself substantiate claims of an impending defection.

Shirsat separately welcomed Nationalist Congress Party (Sharadchandra Pawar) parliamentarian Supriya Sule's position on proposals concerning electoral representation. He argued that growing populations and larger electorates were making it harder for individual representatives to serve their constituencies effectively and that an increase in the number of constituencies could ease those pressures.

He praised Sule for considering the issue beyond party affiliations, saying constructive positions taken by political opponents deserved acknowledgement. Sule had also indicated that no fresh formal government proposal or draft concerning delimitation had been placed before her, leaving the details and timing of any such changes unsettled.

Shirsat's remarks on electoral representation were made alongside his comments on Operation Tiger-3, but concerned a separate policy debate. The questions of constituency boundaries, representation and the reservation ceiling require distinct legal and political decisions; his endorsement of Sule's position was not an announcement of any government measure.

Government sources allege visa breach by Italian politician

Government sources have accused Italian politician Giacomo Filibeck of breaching visa conditions by intervening in India's domestic political debate during a conference in Hyderabad.

The allegation, made on Monday, concerns remarks supporting Congress leader Rahul Gandhi's campaign over electoral rolls. Officials speaking without being named said Filibeck entered India on a conference visa obtained through the government's electronic visa portal and that foreign visitors were prohibited from interfering in domestic politics, regardless of their visa category.

No formal finding of a visa violation or immigration penalty has been publicly confirmed. The sources did not identify the specific visa provision they believed had been breached or explain whether an official investigation had begun.

Filibeck, secretary-general of the Party of European Socialists (PES), attended the Bharat Summit held in Hyderabad on November 13 and 14. During his appearance, he endorsed Gandhi's demands for transparent electoral rolls and repeated the opposition slogan, “Vote Chor, Gaddi Chhod”, loosely meaning “Vote thief, leave office”.

His intervention intensified criticism from the Bharatiya Janata Party, which accused the Congress of allowing a foreign political figure to take sides in a domestic dispute. The governing party has rejected Gandhi's allegations of electoral manipulation, while the Election Commission has maintained that its electoral procedures are lawful.

Telangana BJP president N Ramchander Rao subsequently submitted a complaint to the Foreigners Regional Registration Office, seeking action against Filibeck and the summit organisers over alleged immigration and visa violations. A party delegation also approached Telangana police chief C V Anand demanding legal action concerning statements made at the gathering.

Rao alleged that the conference platform had been used for political attacks and asked immigration authorities to examine the visiting delegate's status. His demand for an inquiry was a political complaint, rather than a determination by the authorities.

The complaints mark a separate step from the government sources' assessment. Filing a complaint does not establish that an offence occurred, and there has been no publicly confirmed adjudication of Filibeck's remarks under immigration law.

The Ministry of Home Affairs' published guidance states that a conference visa is intended for foreign nationals whose sole purpose in visiting India is to attend a conference, seminar or workshop. Its guidance also outlines checks on applicants and the nature of events for which such visas may be issued.

The published eligibility criteria do not, by themselves, establish whether Filibeck's particular statements exceeded the conditions attached to his permission to enter. That question would require examination of the applicable rules and the circumstances of his visit.

Filibeck defended his comments and participation in the summit. Speaking on November 14, he said international gatherings were important for drawing attention to challenges facing democracy, contending that democracy in India was “under attack”. He urged support for Gandhi and Congress, presenting electoral transparency as a matter of wider international concern.

On Monday, the PES issued a statement backing Filibeck after he faced personal attacks on social media. The organisation said he attended the gathering at the invitation of its organisers and had raised concerns about the effect of electoral roll revisions on citizens' voting rights.

The PES reiterated support for Gandhi's campaign and called for transparent scrutiny of revisions, including opportunities for eligible voters to challenge the removal of their names. It acknowledged that the BJP and Election Commission rejected allegations that the exercise had been used to favour the governing party.

Filibeck said the criticism would not silence him. His party presented his remarks as part of cooperation among progressive political organisations, rather than as an attempt to influence an election through any official government role.

The controversy has also drawn criticism from the Bharat Rashtra Samithi, a rival of Congress in Telangana, whose representatives questioned the appropriateness of a visiting politician joining partisan exchanges at a state-hosted international event.

The Hyderabad summit brought together political representatives and other delegates for discussions on democracy and progressive policies. Gandhi, the Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha, attended the gathering and spoke about his concerns regarding the country's democratic institutions.

Filibeck has returned to Italy. Authorities have not publicly announced any decision to restrict his future entry into India. The Party of European Socialists, meanwhile, has said it will continue supporting efforts to ensure that eligible voters can verify their registration and contest deletions from electoral rolls.

Security forces recover body after Kulgam gunfight

Security forces recovered a body and a weapon following Monday’s encounter with suspected militants in Jammu and Kashmir’s Kulgam district, while a search continued for another man believed to have escaped the cordon.

The gunfight took place near Laroo village, in the Larnoo Bypass area, during an operation launched after an attack on Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF) personnel on 11 November. Police said the identity of the person killed would be formally established through identification by family members.

Inspector General of Police for Kashmir Sujit Kumar confirmed that one body had been recovered but cautioned against identifying the deceased before the verification process was completed. Officials involved in the operation said another suspect, believed to be Lashkar-e-Taiba operative Mohammed Lateef Bhat, remained unaccounted for.

Security personnel expanded the cordon around the encounter site and deployed additional search teams. Officials said the search was to resume on Tuesday morning after operations were curtailed overnight, with security personnel maintaining their positions around the affected area.

Jammu and Kashmir Police had announced the encounter on Monday through its Kashmir Zone account on X, saying the entire area had been cordoned off and police and other security forces were conducting the operation. The announcement did not specify the number or identity of the suspected militants involved.

The confrontation followed information received by police about the movement of two suspects near the Laroo bypass. Personnel from the Army and the Special Operations Group of Jammu and Kashmir Police moved towards the location as part of a cordon-and-search operation, according to officials familiar with the deployment.

The suspects were said to have moved towards two schools near an apple orchard after noticing security personnel. Children were present at the premises, prompting officers to prioritise their evacuation before proceeding with the armed operation. Officials said the evacuation took approximately 90 minutes.

Additional Army units and CRPF personnel joined the deployment as the perimeter was secured. The exchange of fire occurred after the civilians had been moved away, according to the account given by security officials. No civilian casualties were announced in the information available from the operation.

Officials subsequently identified the deceased provisionally as Umar Dar, from Arreh village in Kulgam, but police maintained that formal identification was still required. They alleged that he had been associated with Bhat and was suspected of involvement in the attack on CRPF personnel five days earlier. Those allegations have not been established in court.

Bhat was believed by security officials to have escaped the initial cordon, possibly with injuries. His whereabouts had not been confirmed. Security forces continued searching the surrounding orchards and adjoining areas rather than declaring the operation complete.

Director General of Police Nalin Prabhat and Kumar visited Kulgam to supervise the security response. The two senior officers reviewed the operation as teams searched for suspects linked to the earlier attack. Police and paramilitary personnel had already intensified checks in the district during the weekend.

A joint cordon-and-search operation was mounted near Mir Bazar on Sunday, following the 11 November firing at a CRPF checkpoint in the Nowpora Akhran area. Three CRPF personnel were injured when armed assailants opened fire and escaped. The incident prompted a wider effort to locate those responsible.

Security officials have linked Bhat to the checkpoint attack, but his alleged participation and the circumstances of his escape remain matters of investigation. The police have not announced an arrest or provided conclusive evidence identifying everyone involved in the shooting.

Special Director General of the CRPF Sandeep Khirwar said security personnel remained on high alert and multiple operations were underway throughout the district in Kulgam following the checkpoint attack.

The operation on Monday involved personnel from several units operating under a shared security cordon. Additional teams, including Army special forces, were subsequently deployed to examine the area and prevent any remaining suspect from leaving undetected.

Authorities also established lighting arrangements around the search perimeter overnight. Officials said the immediate search activity was suspended until daylight while the cordon remained in place, allowing teams to resume examination of the area without lifting security restrictions.

The location of the encounter lies within Kulgam district, where the earlier attack occurred near Mir Bazar. Police had maintained searches across parts of the district since the checkpoint shooting, with Monday’s operation concentrated around Laroo and the adjoining bypass.

Petitioner challenges Election Commission’s defence of electoral revision

Petitioner Rakesh Kumar Singh has accused the Election Commission of India of concealing procedural failures in its Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls, arguing before the Supreme Court that a unanimously approved affidavit cannot establish that disputed decisions were lawfully taken.

Singh’s rejoinder, filed on November 15, describes the Commission’s response as a “bureaucratic cover-up” and asks the court to examine original records showing who authorised actions undertaken in the poll body’s name. The filing contests affidavits dated October 26 and November 14 and maintains that later agreement among commissioners cannot retrospectively establish approval for earlier administrative decisions.

“Unanimity in defending an act is not unanimity in deciding it,” the petitioner says, distinguishing the Commission’s collective defence of its conduct from the statutory requirement governing its decisions.

The dispute centres on Section 18 of the Chief Election Commissioner and Other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023. It provides for decisions by consensus where possible and majority vote where commissioners differ. Singh argues that officials cannot exercise powers reserved for the three-member constitutional body without valid delegation.

The Commission rejects suggestions of unilateral decision-making. Its October affidavit says the principal SIR orders of June 24, 2025, October 27, 2025 and May 14, 2026 were approved unanimously. It also says its affidavit was endorsed by Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar and Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi.

Deputy Election Commissioner Bhanu Prakash Yeturu affirmed the Commission’s affidavits. The poll body says members’ observations and questions on files are part of deliberations rather than binding decisions, while statutory provisions and standing orders permit designated officers to perform delegated functions. It says urgent approvals may be obtained electronically and recorded on files afterwards, without requiring a physical meeting of commissioners.

Singh disputes that explanation, identifying 20 statements in the Commission’s filings which, he contends, reveal actions by officials or divisions without decisions recorded by the full Commission. He wants the original files, approval sheets, meeting records and electronic audit trails produced so the court can distinguish authorised decisions from subsequent explanations.

One contested issue concerns an additional declaration incorporated into the online Form 6 process during the electoral revision. Singh contends that applicants had to provide information linking themselves or relatives to earlier electoral rolls although changes to the statutory form require legal authority. The Commission maintains that Form 6 itself was never amended and that the declaration was separate.

The petitioner says the Commission’s decision to separate the declaration from the online form on October 21 does not resolve whether its earlier use was authorised. He also questions whether objections recorded by the two Election Commissioners were properly reflected in the eventual administrative action.

Another dispute concerns appeals filed by electoral officials in West Bengal against findings that certain voters were eligible. Singh says the Commission acknowledged that these appeals were not placed before the three members and asks whether any lawful delegation authorised their filing. The Commission’s position on its wider delegation arrangements remains part of the contested proceedings.

The rejoinder also challenges the geographical scope of relief offered to electors omitted from draft rolls. Singh points to directions issued on November 6 to seven states and Union Territories and asks why equivalent opportunities were not extended across all areas undergoing the revision.

Those directions allow certain excluded electors to submit enumeration forms and provide for restoration of their earlier voter identification numbers following verification. The Commission says the measures were designed to prevent eligible electors being excluded while guarding against duplicate enrolment.

Its November 14 affidavit further clarifies that people omitted during the revision will not face prosecution merely because they submit Form 6 despite having appeared on earlier rolls, provided they are not registered elsewhere and their declarations otherwise comply with the law.

Singh has asked the court to require identification of the authority, date and recorded approval supporting each challenged action. He also seeks preservation of relevant files and electronic records, alongside procedures ensuring that future Commission decisions are properly documented.

The petition, registered as a civil writ proceeding against the Union of India and others, is listed before Chief Justice Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana on November 17. The Supreme Court permitted further affidavits when it considered the connected petitions on October 27.

European socialists defend Filibeck after Hyderabad speech backlash

The Party of European Socialists has defended its secretary general, Giacomo Filibeck, after he faced hostile social media attacks over his endorsement of Rahul Gandhi’s campaign challenging the integrity of electoral rolls in India.

The Brussels-based organisation said on Monday that Filibeck would not be silenced by criticism following his address to the Bharat Summit in Hyderabad on November 14. His remarks have also prompted a formal complaint from the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), which alleges interference by a foreign political figure in domestic affairs.

Filibeck accused BJP supporters of targeting him online and reaffirmed his support for efforts to protect voting rights. “I stand by what I said,” he declared in a statement issued by the Party of European Socialists (PES) on November 16.

He said he respected the country's democratic institutions but was concerned about eligible voters discovering that their names had disappeared from electoral registers. He maintained that every eligible citizen should be able to vote and challenge an exclusion before polling.

The PES backed that position, calling for transparent scrutiny of electoral roll revisions and accessible procedures for voters to establish why their names were deleted. It also endorsed the Congress campaign for accountability, while stopping short of presenting the opposition's allegations of deliberate manipulation as established fact.

The dispute widened on Monday when the BJP's Telangana unit approached the Foreigners Regional Registration Office and submitted a complaint to state police. State BJP president N. Ramchander Rao sought legal action against Filibeck and the summit organisers, alleging that his intervention breached visa conditions and undermined national sovereignty.

Rao also demanded apologies from Gandhi and Telangana Chief Minister A. Revanth Reddy for permitting the remarks at the gathering. The complaint remains an allegation; no finding of a visa violation or criminal wrongdoing was established in the information made public on Monday.

Government sources separately suggested that Filibeck entered the country on a conference visa and that political intervention by a foreign visitor could breach applicable conditions. The claim has added an immigration dimension to the confrontation, although an official determination or enforcement order has not been announced.

The row began after Filibeck repeated the Congress slogan “Vote chor, gaddi chhod”, broadly meaning “Vote thief, vacate your seat”, during the two-day summit, held on November 13 and 14. Gandhi, the Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha, attended the event.

Filibeck praised Gandhi's demands for clean electoral rolls and said protecting the principle of one person, one vote was a shared democratic responsibility. Speaking at the organisers' invitation, he urged international attention to the consequences of the Election Commission's Special Intensive Revision exercise.

The Congress contends that the revision process has removed legitimate voters and benefited the BJP. Both the governing party and the Election Commission reject allegations of politically motivated deletions. The Commission maintains that its procedures are lawful and intended to include eligible voters while excluding ineligible entries.

The controversy has attracted criticism beyond India. Deborah Bergamini, national deputy secretary of Italy's Forza Italia party, challenged Filibeck's remarks and defended India's electoral institutions. She argued that outsiders should not lecture a country whose electorate numbers hundreds of millions.

Parliamentary Affairs Minister Kiren Rijiju also criticised Gandhi's reaction to the speech, questioning why he appeared amused when a visiting politician criticised the country. BJP leaders have characterised the remarks as an improper attempt to enlist international backing for domestic opposition politics.

Filibeck rejected the suggestion that criticism should deter international engagement on democratic rights. The PES statement placed the dispute alongside wider concerns about political opposition, independent media and judicial institutions, while asserting that democratic disagreements must be resolved through fair rules.

The electoral roll exercise has faced judicial scrutiny, including intervention by the Supreme Court over exclusions in Bihar. Around 6.5 million names were omitted from that state's draft roll, although removal from a draft does not by itself establish permanent disenfranchisement. Electoral authorities provide processes for claims and objections. The Supreme Court directed the publication of excluded names and the reasons for their omission, seeking to make the exercise more transparent for affected voters and enable timely, effective challenges to individual decisions.

At Hyderabad, Filibeck also advocated continued cooperation among progressive parties, trade unions and civil society organisations, describing electoral participation and political accountability as issues of concern across national borders.

Congress seeks 181 Uttar Pradesh seats, Akhilesh confirms

Congress has sought 181 seats for the 2027 Uttar Pradesh Assembly elections, Samajwadi Party president Akhilesh Yadav disclosed on Saturday, while insisting that the opposition alliance would remain intact.

Speaking at the Hindustan Times Leadership Summit in New Delhi on November 14, Yadav said his party had already decided how many constituencies it wanted to contest. He did not disclose that figure or announce an agreement on the Congress demand.

The disclosure places the two allies' competing electoral ambitions at the centre of negotiations over the 403-member Assembly. Congress's request amounts to nearly 45 per cent of the constituencies, although the eventual distribution remains unsettled.

Congress subsequently announced that formal seat-sharing discussions with the Samajwadi Party would begin on November 17. Rajendra Pal Gautam, the Congress leader responsible for Uttar Pradesh, said the parties would examine the constituencies each wanted to contest before determining the final allocation.

The constituency-by-constituency exercise will require both parties to compare their preferred candidates and local electoral assessments. Neither leader provided a timetable for the completion of a final binding seat-sharing agreement on Saturday.

Gautam told a press conference in Lucknow that the precise number would become clear through discussions. He said both parties would consider individual seats and the competing claims surrounding them, rather than treating an initial demand as a completed arrangement.

Yadav disclosed the Congress figure during an exchange about the scale of its request. Asked whether Congress wanted 100 seats, he said the number was higher. He indicated it was below 200 before confirming that 181 was the figure being discussed.

Describing relations with Congress as very good, Yadav maintained that the Samajwadi Party and the opposition INDIA bloc would jointly challenge the Bharatiya Janata Party, which governs Uttar Pradesh under Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath.

He rejected suggestions that the composition of the existing alliance might change. Asked whether he was considering joining forces with Bahujan Samaj Party leader Mayawati, Yadav said he was not exploring alternative alliances while committed to the present arrangement.

His comments establish that negotiations concern the distribution of seats rather than an announced rupture between the partners. They do not, however, establish that the Samajwadi Party has accepted Congress's request or that either party has finalised its candidates.

Congress has been seeking what Gautam described as an equal and honourable share of constituencies. He said in October that the party had submitted a list containing between 150 and 200 seats for consideration by its ally, providing context for the figure Yadav disclosed.

The two parties contested the 2024 Lok Sabha elections together in Uttar Pradesh. The Samajwadi Party won 37 parliamentary constituencies and Congress secured six, giving their partnership a stronger electoral position than either had enjoyed during the preceding Assembly contest.

Their performance is central to the present bargaining because the partners must decide how parliamentary gains translate into Assembly nominations. Parliamentary results, however, do not automatically determine the distribution of seats in a state election involving different constituencies and candidates.

Congress won only two Assembly seats when it contested the 2022 state election independently. The Samajwadi Party secured 111 seats, while the BJP retained power. Those outcomes provide a contrasting measure of the parties' organisational strength before their parliamentary alliance.

Yadav also used the summit to criticise the BJP government's record on employment and law and order. He raised examination paper leaks, recruitment grievances and the Agniveer military recruitment scheme among issues he said would feature in the opposition's campaign.

He questioned the government's use of bulldozers against properties, alleging that vulnerable communities had suffered disproportionately. These criticisms represent the opposition leader's allegations rather than findings established by his remarks at the summit.

Yadav further said alleged irregularities involving donations associated with the Ram temple in Ayodhya would become an election issue. His accusation was not accompanied by evidence establishing wrongdoing during the discussion.

The Samajwadi Party has said it plans to release its Jan-Man Manifesto on November 26, Constitution Day, setting out proposals for the approaching contest. The announcement provides another date on the opposition's election calendar alongside the scheduled seat-sharing talks.

At Saturday's Lucknow press conference, Uttar Pradesh Congress president Aradhana Mishra said district leaders had been instructed to inspect electoral rolls. She described party workers as guardians of votes, placing voter-list scrutiny among the Congress organisation's immediate preparations.

Blinken urges terrorism crackdown and independent India policy

Former US Secretary of State Antony Blinken has called for zero tolerance towards terrorism and recognition of India's right to defend itself, while insisting that Washington must treat its relations with New Delhi separately from those with Pakistan.

Speaking at the Hindustan Times Leadership Summit in New Delhi on Saturday, November 14, Blinken described the two relationships as fundamentally different. He said cooperation with India extended across global challenges, whereas engagement with Pakistan remained largely focused on regional security, including counterterrorism.

“We have to have a zero-tolerance policy for terrorism. Period. And that means that we have to have respect for India's right to defend itself,” Blinken said during a conversation with Jawed Ashraf, chairman of the India Trade Promotion Organisation.

He coupled that position with a warning about the dangers of military escalation between India and Pakistan. Washington, he argued, should respect New Delhi's ability to respond to attacks while supporting diplomacy to prevent a confrontation between the nuclear-armed neighbours. The consequences of a conflict could extend well beyond their borders.

His formulation separated two responsibilities that can become difficult to reconcile during a crisis: acknowledging the right to respond to terrorism and working to contain the resulting confrontation. He placed particular emphasis on the destructive potential of nuclear weapons, arguing that efforts to prevent escalation were essential for both countries and others exposed to the consequences of conflict.

Blinken said the longstanding practice of interpreting Washington's ties with India through its relationship with Pakistan had ended. The change reflected a reassessment of American strategic priorities following the Cold War and the US withdrawal from Afghanistan, where cooperation with Islamabad had once been central to Washington's calculations.

“India is a global force,” he said, describing the two countries' shared interests and areas of disagreement as international rather than simply regional. By contrast, Washington's dealings with Islamabad involved a narrower set of objectives, although he made clear that cooperation with Pakistan on counterterrorism would remain important.

The former secretary of state also examined the consequences of Washington's earlier reliance on Pakistan. Strategic considerations involving the Soviet Union and subsequently Afghanistan, he suggested, had encouraged successive US administrations to exercise insufficient scrutiny over Pakistan's military establishment and its relationship with civilian governments.

He said the United States had an opportunity to encourage a different balance between civilian and military authority in Pakistan. However, he cautioned that the outcome could not be dictated from abroad. Decisions about the country's political institutions and the character of its government ultimately belonged to Pakistan's people.

The distinction also underscored his argument that policy towards one neighbour should not automatically determine the broader scope, priorities or ambitions of American engagement with the other.

His comments came amid scrutiny of Washington's dealings with Islamabad under President Donald Trump, whose administration has maintained contact with Pakistan's leadership. Blinken did not suggest that the United States should abandon its relationship with Pakistan. Rather, he distinguished cooperation on specific security matters from the wider strategic partnership with India.

Turning to that partnership, Blinken described a substantial transformation from a period of mutual estrangement to close cooperation. He identified convergence on strategic interests and extensive connections between the two societies as important foundations, while acknowledging that disagreements would continue to arise between governments pursuing their own priorities.

Technology, he said, would be a major area for the next phase of bilateral engagement. He pointed to opportunities for collaboration in space, quantum technology and artificial intelligence, presenting these fields as areas where both countries could pursue shared objectives. Cooperation on emerging technologies, he indicated, would increasingly shape the practical substance of their relationship.

Blinken also addressed New Delhi's longstanding relationship with Moscow, saying Washington understood its historical foundations and did not expect India to sever those connections. Differences over Russia, he suggested, need not prevent the United States and India from working together where their interests converged. His remarks reflected an acknowledgement that cooperation does not require identical foreign policy positions.

Blinken served as secretary of state under President Joe Biden from 2021 until 2025. At the summit, he also discussed broader changes in international affairs, including technological disruption and widening inequalities. He warned that weakening cooperation among American government agencies, universities and research institutions could damage the United States' capacity to compete in an increasingly demanding technological environment.

Cockroach Janta Party appoints coordinators across ten regions

The Cockroach Janta Party (CJP) has appointed two zonal leaders and established coordination committees across 10 states and regions, moving to build a grassroots organisation beyond its original youth protest network.

The appointments, announced on November 14, give Kshitij Pagar responsibility for the West Zone and Dr Vivek Sangwan for the North Zone. Muhammad Junaid and Geegraj Jorli have joined the North Zone Coordination Committee, while separate panels have been constituted for nine states and the Northeast.

The new bodies cover Jammu and Kashmir, Rajasthan, West Bengal, Haryana, Jharkhand, Maharashtra, Uttar Pradesh, Bihar and Uttarakhand, alongside a committee serving the northeastern region. Their stated remit includes coordinating local activities, recruiting supporters and providing channels for raising public concerns.

Uttar Pradesh has the largest committee, with 16 members, followed by Maharashtra with 15. Jharkhand and the Northeast have 14 each, Bihar 13 and West Bengal 12. Haryana and Uttarakhand have six members apiece, Rajasthan five and Jammu and Kashmir four.

Despite its name and the expansion into politically significant states, CJP says it does not intend to contest elections. National media coordinator Subhasree Das has described the organisation as a political pressure group, saying it has no plans to establish an electoral party. She said the appointments were not driven by any particular election.

That distinction is significant in Uttar Pradesh, where Assembly elections are approaching. The organisation's decision to establish its largest state committee there nevertheless places it within a politically active environment, while its leadership maintains that its purpose is public mobilisation rather than seeking seats in legislatures.

Das said the decision to expand followed six months of activity and was intended to give people more opportunities to raise concerns ranging from neighbourhood problems to students’ grievances. She said the appointments were part of a planned organisational exercise. The distinction between advocacy and electoral competition remains part of the group’s stated position: its representatives say they want to scrutinise elected officials rather than field candidates against them. The announced structure includes both state committees and a northeastern panel, rather than a committee for each northeastern state.

Ajinkya Shinde, CJP's national organisation in-charge, said committee members would seek accountability from elected representatives over their work and electoral promises. The organisation is initially focusing on Lok Sabha constituencies, with plans to extend its network to Assembly constituencies as membership increases.

The group has begun an offline membership campaign, including outreach at colleges and public places in Maharashtra and Haryana. It is also distributing QR codes for online enrolment and generating digital identity cards for those who register, combining personal recruitment with the online methods through which it first attracted attention.

Shinde said those selected for the new posts included people involved in the organisation since its protest at Delhi's Jantar Mantar. Das described the committees as comprising largely young professionals and students, including people working in information technology and law. Some members have left employment to participate, while others continue their jobs alongside organisational duties.

Founded by Abhijeet Dipke in May, CJP began as a satirical online response to remarks by Chief Justice of India Surya Kant referring to unemployed young people as cockroaches. It subsequently developed into a campaign platform centred on youth unemployment, alleged examination irregularities and demands for greater accountability from public institutions.

Its activities included a 36-day demonstration at Jantar Mantar concerning the controversy surrounding the National Eligibility cum Entrance Test for undergraduate medical admissions. Protesters demanded action over alleged irregularities and called for the resignation of then education minister Dharmendra Pradhan.

CJP subsequently broadened its agenda to the Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls, questioning the process and calling for the resignation of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar. It also supported the opposition INDIA bloc's November 1 demonstration in Delhi against the revision exercise, although that support did not amount to an announcement of electoral participation.

The organisation's Jammu and Kashmir coordination committee comprises advocate Murtaza Kamaal, Mudassir Manzoor, Dr Pranav Singh and Tahira Bano. Their inclusion was publicised in the group's organisational announcements, giving the Union Territory a four-member team within the new structure.

CJP has not publicly specified detailed individual assignments or operating timetables for every member of the newly announced committees. Its stated immediate responsibilities for the panels remain regional coordination, constituency outreach and the extension of its membership network.

European socialist leader echoes Congress slogan at summit

Italian politician Giacomo Filibeck’s endorsement of Rahul Gandhi’s electoral campaign at the Bharat Summit in Hyderabad has triggered a political dispute, with the BJP accusing Congress of inviting foreign interference in domestic affairs.

Filibeck, secretary-general of the Party of European Socialists, used the Congress slogan “vote chor, gaddi chhod” during Saturday’s gathering and translated it as “vote thief, leave your seat”. He also declared that democracy in India was “under attack” and urged international political movements to support Gandhi and his party.

The remarks prompted criticism from BJP leaders on Sunday, November 15, including Parliamentary Affairs Minister Kiren Rijiju, who questioned Gandhi’s visible amusement during Filibeck’s speech. Congress representatives rejected the criticism, arguing that the remarks reflected concerns about electoral integrity rather than improper foreign intervention.

Filibeck told the summit that Gandhi had defended the fundamental democratic principle of “one person, one vote”. He praised the opposition leader’s campaign for transparent electoral rolls and referred to supporters who had marched to Delhi’s Ramlila Maidan in protest against alleged electoral irregularities.

“Democracy is under attack in India, and we need to defend it,” Filibeck said while discussing the purpose of international political gatherings. He argued that supporting Gandhi and Congress was the best way to defend democratic institutions, presenting the two as partners of progressive movements elsewhere.

His comments represented an explicit endorsement of a domestic opposition campaign by a senior European political figure. The Party of European Socialists brings together socialist and social democratic political parties in Europe, while Congress has participated in international discussions among progressive organisations.

Rijiju responded on social media by asking whether anyone had seen a politician laughing when the country was insulted by a foreigner. His remarks targeted Gandhi, who appeared to laugh and applaud as Filibeck repeated the slogan from the stage.

Union Minister of State for Home Affairs Bandi Sanjay Kumar accused the Congress government in Telangana, led by Chief Minister A Revanth Reddy, of giving foreign representatives a platform to interfere in domestic politics. He argued that the country’s democracy belonged to its citizens and should not become a subject of partisan intervention by overseas guests.

Telangana BJP president N Ramchander Rao also criticised Gandhi’s reaction, questioning why foreign political figures were being permitted to challenge the country’s democratic credentials at the event. BJP leader Shahnawaz Hussain called Filibeck’s comments unacceptable and said overseas politicians had no right to intervene in domestic political disputes.

Congress MP Pramod Tiwari responded that the BJP should examine the substance of the criticism rather than object to the nationality of the speaker. He suggested that a foreign delegate repeating accusations about electoral practices should prompt introspection by the government.

Congress spokesperson Girija Shetkar questioned the consistency of the BJP’s objections, citing Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s public reference to Donald Trump during a political gathering in Houston in 2019. Her intervention sought to distinguish expressions of international political solidarity from accusations of unwarranted interference.

Shiv Sena (UBT) leader Sanjay Raut also defended Filibeck’s right to speak, arguing that concerns about democracy and human rights could legitimately be raised in an international forum. His comments underscored differences among political parties over whether the European leader’s intervention crossed an acceptable boundary.

The underlying electoral allegations remain contested. Gandhi and Congress have accused the BJP and election authorities of failing to protect the integrity of voter lists, while the BJP has rejected the opposition’s allegations. Filibeck did not offer independent evidence establishing electoral manipulation during the remarks that generated the dispute.

The summit brought together Congress leaders, delegates from allied political movements and international participants. Gandhi addressed its valedictory session on November 14 and alleged that several invited delegates had been prevented by the central government from entering the country despite having visas. That assertion was presented by Gandhi without publicly disclosed supporting details in his speech.

Filibeck also linked his intervention to social justice, climate justice and human rights, describing those priorities as shared commitments of the progressive alliance. During the summit’s closing session, he referred to political pressures on opposition groups, courts and journalists in several countries, including India, Turkey and the United States.

He called for the release of Istanbul mayor Ekrem Imamoglu and others he described as unjustly imprisoned, while voicing support for Ukraine and Palestine and a stronger role for emerging economies.

Factual discrepancies surface across Sonia Gandhi's political memoir

Congress Parliamentary Party chairperson Sonia Gandhi's memoir, Belonging: A Journey of Love, has drawn scrutiny over inaccurate election figures, ministerial designations and historical dates, with further discrepancies identified in accounts of her family's political career.

Among the errors is the description of Rahul Gandhi as a four-term member of Parliament. His victory from Rae Bareli in the 2024 Lok Sabha election marked his fifth parliamentary term, following victories in 2004, 2009, 2014 and 2019. The description appears towards the end of the book, where Gandhi discusses her children's political roles.

Another discrepancy concerns the ministerial responsibilities of senior Congress leaders during a political conversation in 2010. Gandhi identifies P Chidambaram as finance minister while describing tensions involving Pranab Mukherjee and a suggestion that leadership at the top might need to change. Mukherjee, however, held the finance portfolio at the time, while Chidambaram was home minister. Chidambaram returned to finance in July 2012, following Mukherjee's resignation to contest the presidential election.

The account of the 1984 Lok Sabha election also contains a numerical error. Gandhi says Congress secured 405 seats out of a 544-member lower house following Indira Gandhi's assassination. Congress won 404 seats in the election, held for 542 constituencies. The book elsewhere uses the correct figure of 404, leaving an inconsistency within its account of the same election.

The memoir also places the National Democratic Alliance's 2014 election tally at 353 seats, although the alliance won 336. The Bharatiya Janata Party secured 282 seats that year. The higher alliance figure belongs to the 2019 general election, suggesting the book has combined results from two different contests.

The discrepancies extend to organisational history. A passage discussing the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh gives its founding year as 1921. The organisation was established in Nagpur in 1925 by Keshav Baliram Hedgewar. The incorrect date appears in a discussion of ideological differences between Congress and the RSS, rather than an account of Gandhi's personal experiences.

Gandhi also places the death of Ahmed Patel, her longtime political secretary, in 2022, saying he succumbed to Covid. Patel died on 25 November 2020 following complications associated with the infection. He had been a key intermediary between Congress and its coalition partners, making his death a significant event in the party's organisational history.

Other passages have attracted questions about constitutional procedures. The book describes Lok Sabha members as elected and Rajya Sabha members as nominated. Most members of the upper house are elected indirectly through state legislative assemblies, while the President nominates 12 members. Sonia Gandhi herself entered the Rajya Sabha in 2024 after serving several terms in the Lok Sabha.

The account of Rahul Gandhi's 2023 criminal defamation proceedings also confuses judicial decisions. A magistrate's court in Surat sentenced him to two years' imprisonment in March 2023 over remarks made in 2019. The Supreme Court stayed his conviction on 4 August 2023, allowing his parliamentary membership to be restored three days later. That was not a suspension of his sentence followed by reinstatement a year later.

Chronological problems appear in the book's description of the Kargil conflict. It places Atal Bihari Vajpayee with Pakistan's prime minister Nawaz Sharif when infiltrators were detected in May 1999. Vajpayee had visited Lahore in February, more than two months earlier. His government also lost a confidence vote in April 1999, not a no-confidence motion.

The book dates Anna Hazare's emergence as the face of the anti-corruption movement to 2012, although his prominent protest at Jantar Mantar in New Delhi began in April 2011. Its discussion of the 2002 Gujarat violence also calls Ahmedabad the state capital, rather than Gandhinagar.

The memoir, released on 10 November, combines Gandhi's personal recollections of Rajiv Gandhi and the Nehru-Gandhi family with accounts of elections, governments and diplomatic encounters. An examination has identified 55 factual and contextual issues, although these range from demonstrable mistakes to disputes about how events are presented. The errors do not, by themselves, establish deliberate misrepresentation.

Among the diplomatic inaccuracies, the book places Nelson Mandela's Bharat Ratna visit in 1991 instead of 1990. It also identifies the leader of India's delegation to Mandela's 1994 inauguration as President R K Narayan. The delegation was headed by Vice-President K R Narayanan. Another passage calls Deng Xiaoping China's president during Rajiv Gandhi's 1988 visit, although that office was held by Yang Shangkun.

Bandi Sanjay declares Telangana Bharat Summit a failure

Union Minister of State for Home Affairs Bandi Sanjay Kumar on Saturday called the Telangana government's Bharat Summit in Hyderabad a “complete failure”, claiming that Congress leader Rahul Gandhi's departure before the event ended demonstrated its lack of success.

The Bharatiya Janata Party leader made the allegation in a video statement on November 14, intensifying a dispute over the gathering, where Gandhi addressed delegates and criticised the state of democracy under Prime Minister Narendra Modi.

Sanjay offered no evidence that Gandhi's departure reflected the summit's outcome. Gandhi, the Leader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha, had addressed its valedictory session, according to a statement issued by the Congress party.

The minister also accused Gandhi of using the international platform to disparage the country and discuss domestic political disputes before foreign representatives. He characterised the gathering as an “anti-India summit”, alleging that people opposed to the country's progress had assembled there.

His criticism followed Gandhi's assertion that India's democratic institutions had suffered under the BJP-led government since 2014. Gandhi told the gathering that democratic debate required a willingness to listen to opposing views and attacked political leaders he described as fascists.

Sanjay rejected that assessment, accusing the Congress of concentrating power within the Gandhi family. He questioned whether an ordinary party worker could rise to its leadership without the family's approval and challenged Gandhi to examine democratic practices within his own organisation.

“First, bring democracy back into your party. Then talk about democracy in the country!” Sanjay said.

He also invoked the Emergency imposed under a previous Congress government and the anti-Sikh violence of 1984, arguing that the opposition party had its own record to answer for when discussing democratic rights. His references formed part of a wider political rebuttal rather than evidence concerning the summit's organisation.

The minister disputed Gandhi's allegations about electoral roll deletions. He said removing the names of deceased voters, duplicate entries and people who had permanently moved was necessary to maintain accurate electoral records. He also questioned whether people who were not eligible to vote should remain registered.

Sanjay accused Gandhi of challenging electronic voting machines, ballot papers and the Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls depending on electoral outcomes. Those criticisms concerned the opposition leader's political positions and did not establish whether any particular allegation of electoral malpractice was true.

Addressing Gandhi's claims about spending during the 2014 general election, Sanjay urged him to produce evidence before the Election Commission and seek judicial scrutiny rather than make allegations in public.

Telangana Chief Minister A Revanth Reddy, meanwhile, has defended the summit as an opportunity to introduce the state to policymakers, thinkers and potential investors from abroad. He accused the BJP and the Bharat Rashtra Samithi of obstructing government initiatives for political reasons.

Reddy said the government had expected 1,000 delegates from 70 countries and hoped their participation would strengthen Telangana's international connections. These were the organisers' expectations, not independently verified final attendance figures.

The chief minister also alleged that the central government had prevented some invited international delegates from travelling to India, including through visa restrictions. Gandhi echoed those complaints during his summit address and apologised to those unable to attend. The disputed circumstances of individual visa decisions were not established at the gathering.

The two-day event brought together political figures and policy specialists from different countries. It was backed by the Telangana government and presented as a forum for discussing democracy, development and international cooperation.

The political confrontation extended outside the venue on Saturday. Activists affiliated with the Bharatiya Janata Yuva Morcha protested near the Hyderabad International Convention Centre, shouted slogans against Gandhi and displayed placards. Police detained protesters and moved them away from the premises.

Gandhi also participated in a programme concerning social security and welfare for gig workers during his Hyderabad visit. Telangana's government promoted the initiative alongside the summit, while BJP leaders questioned its record on commitments to other sections of the workforce.

Sanjay separately challenged the state government over promises to tenant farmers, asking why they were represented at the summit when, he alleged, their concerns remained unresolved.

Before Saturday's remarks, he had sought accounts of spending on the gathering and questioned the use of public funds. He also demanded information about expenditure and outcomes associated with an earlier summit, including investments, employment and implementation of commitments.