Loading…
Just in:
Loading latest syndicated reports…

Top stories

Updated continuously

Supreme Court notifies parties over Ramlila protest challenge

The Supreme Court has sought responses from four political and student organisations over a petition by Delhi traders demanding that Ramlila Maidan lose its status as a designated protest venue, alleging demonstrations disrupt business and livelihoods.

A bench comprising Chief Justice Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana issued notices on Wednesday to the Congress, Cockroach Janata Party (CJP), All India Students Association (AISA) and Aam Aadmi Party (AAP). It also sought replies from the central government, Delhi government and Delhi Police Commissioner.

The court is expected to consider the traders' petition alongside proceedings concerning restrictions on demonstrations and the right to protest on November 27. The judges indicated that competing claims involving public assembly and commercial activity should be examined together rather than in isolation.

The petition was filed by the Delhi Kirana Committee and the Delhi Iron and Hardware Merchants' Association. The two bodies want the October 11 police order designating Ramlila Maidan as a protest venue overturned, arguing that the ground is surrounded by densely populated neighbourhoods and busy wholesale markets.

Senior advocate Mukul Rohatgi, representing the traders, told the bench that protests around central Delhi had interfered with commercial activity. He challenged the suitability of Ramlila Maidan, pointing to its location amid markets where businesses depend on uninterrupted customer access and the movement of goods.

The traders contend that demonstrations create road closures, congestion and access problems affecting not only shopkeepers but also vendors, employees, drivers and people living nearby. Their petition asks for safeguards covering the size and duration of gatherings, traffic management and continued access to residential areas, hospitals and public transport.

The bench had asked the petitioners on November 3 to include organisations responsible for the demonstrations as respondents, observing that affected parties should have an opportunity to be heard before orders were passed. Wednesday's notices followed the filing of the amended petition naming the four organisations.

The dispute places two sets of rights before the court. The organisations have been involved in protests concerning the Election Commission and restrictions on public demonstrations, while the traders maintain that their freedom to conduct business should not be disproportionately affected by protest arrangements.

Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, appearing for the Centre, supported considering the traders' concerns alongside petitions asserting the right to protest. He characterised the proceedings as involving competing rights of demonstrators, traders, workers and residents, making a combined hearing appropriate. The linked proceedings concern the extent to which authorities can regulate assemblies without extinguishing the ability of citizens and groups to demonstrate peacefully.

The court has not decided whether Ramlila Maidan should be removed from the list of approved demonstration venues. Issuing notices requires the respondents to address the allegations and legal demands; it does not establish that the named organisations acted unlawfully or caused the losses alleged by the petitioners.

Delhi Police designated Ramlila Maidan, Burari Ground and CBD Ground in east Delhi as protest venues through an order dated October 11, while removing Jantar Mantar from that list. The order followed recommendations from a committee constituted by the Union home ministry to examine alternative locations for demonstrations.

The traders' petition questions whether sufficient consideration was given to the effects on surrounding neighbourhoods and commerce before Ramlila Maidan was selected. It seeks a fresh assessment that takes account of nearby markets and arrangements for gatherings, rather than a blanket prohibition on peaceful political activity.

The challenge also follows a November 1 opposition rally at Ramlila Maidan organised by the Congress and its allies, which brought demonstrators to the area during the festive trading period. The traders argue that such events can affect sales at markets including Chawri Bazar, Chandni Chowk, Khari Baoli and Sadar Bazar.

The associations have claimed substantial financial losses from interrupted trade, particularly during weeks when seasonal demand supports a large share of annual turnover. Their estimates remain allegations before the court, and no judicial finding has established the value of any losses attributable to demonstrations. The organisations named in the amended petition have yet to present their responses to assertions before the bench.

The petitioners also seek clearer rules on potential damage to property and responsibility for maintaining access during public gatherings. Separate proceedings concerning police restrictions and alleged noncompliance with court directions are being handled within the wider group of protest-related cases.